Plow Boy Tobacco Survey *** Info Added 11-18-2016***

[sb1]

I am attempting to ascertain a correct checklist for the 1910-1912 Spaulding & Merrick Plow Boy Tobacco cabinet set.

Could anyone who has them(even if it's one or two), post their holdings in this thread. Once there are several posts' I will start a tally or checklist on this first post and keep it updated. At the very least we will get an idea of population as well as a checklist. (I decided to not keep a tally of the number of each player, just compile a checklist as they come in. (some I have added were from PM's.)

**********UPDATE 11-18-2016**************

I have now added all of the ones on the PSA and SGC pop report. As you will see this matches the 1992 reprint set.

Archer
Beaumont
Blackburne
Block
Brown
Carson
Chance
Cole
Collins
Dougherty
Evers
Gandel(Gandil)
Hahn
Hoffman
Kling
Kroh
Lange
Luderus
McIntyre
Mullen
Needham
Olmstead
Overall
Parent
Payne
Pfeffer
Pfeister
Purtell
Reulbach
Richie
Schulte
Scott
Scot(incorrect) added Nov 2016
Sheckard
Smith
Steinfeldt
Sullivan
Tinker
Walsh
White
Young
Zeider
Zimmerman

My question now is........Can anyone confirm Bodie, Cicotte, Davis, Howard, Jones, Miller or Tannehill?

[Vintagecatcher]

Scott,

Here is my only one. Tom Needham, Chicago Cubs.

Patrick

[timn1]

Hi Scott,
is Frank Smith of the White Sox (bought from Leon a while back)-

Tim

[Kawika]

Got this beauty as a type card. Am looking forward to this thread. Plow Boys don't get enough love.

[pbspelly]

Sullivan

[pete zouras]

My type is an Overall.

[Epps]

I have a Gandil. I know that Cicotte is on the checklist, but in 13 years of looking for one, I've never seen one or even heard of it being confirmed. I seriously doubt that it exists.

[Bridwell]

I have Dougherty.

[uffda51]

I have Tinker, Evers & Chance. It only took 17 years . . .

[ecRich]

Here's mine.

[sb1]

Thanks to everyone contributing! I have updated the #1 post with all of the confirmed/graded cards. Can anyone confirm the ones at the end of the post?

[Leon]

Originally Posted by sb1

Thanks to everyone contributing! I have updated the #1 post with all of the confirmed/graded cards. Can anyone confirm the ones at the end of the post?

Seems like you might have solved a small mystery.....nicely done.

[fisherman451]

just herd a rumor that 35 plow boy cards sufaced at Fanatic card show yesterday

[sb1]

Bumped and changed to add the Scot(Incorrect) to the checklist. Can anyone confirm any of the remaining seven:

Bodie, Cicotte, Davis, Howard, Jones, Miller, Tannehill