Let's go one step further

[talkinbaseball]

If Derek Jeter played 24 years like Pete Rose, do you think he would've caught him for most hits lifetime?

thanks,
john

[DaClyde]

No. Pete just played a lot more games. Jeter doesn't have a single 162 under his belt, Rose had 8. Jeter just wouldn't have enough games under his belt to get there.

[I Only Smoke 4 the Cards]

I remember when he used to be on pace to break that record. I think that Jeter could have done it if given the ABs. However Rose was willing to change positions and switch teams. Jeter was only willing to play SS for the Yankees.

[DaClyde]

Originally Posted by I Only Smoke 4 the Cards

I remember when he used to be on pace to break that record. I think that Jeter could have done it if given the ABs. However Rose was willing to change positions and switch teams. Jeter was only willing to play SS for the Yankees.

Yes, Rose was basically the sport's greatest utility player whereas Jeter is ONLY a shortstop. If Rose had played in the AL at all in his career, he might have added another 200 hits to his total as a DH. Either Jeter just doesn't like to DH, or the Yankees think they should have a .220-.240 hitting power guy in there out of a sense of tradition. Neither attitude benefits the team or helps Jeter get to 4000 hits.

[I Only Smoke 4 the Cards]

Originally Posted by DaClyde

Yes, Rose was basically the sport's greatest utility player whereas Jeter is ONLY a shortstop. If Rose had played in the AL at all in his career, he might have added another 200 hits to his total as a DH. Either Jeter just doesn't like to DH, or the Yankees think they should have a .220-.240 hitting power guy in there out of a sense of tradition. Neither attitude benefits the team or helps Jeter get to 4000 hits.

Jason - It seems that most teams like power hitters as DH regardless of average. That has never made sense to me. There was a time when Jeter would have been a good OBP guy at DH.

[Exhibitman]

Jeter would have caught Rose if Jeter had the drive to last in the game for as long as it would take to catch Rose, regardless of where or how he played. Rose would have kept going if he could have found a team to take him. Jeter doesn't have that mentality, so he is going out now as a decent player but on his own terms. More power to him for that. You don't want to see another Rickey Henderson situation, trucking around indie minors teams trying to find any MLB club to take him. That's just sad IMO.

[brewing]

Originally Posted by Exhibitman

Jeter would have caught Rose if Jeter had the drive to last in the game for as long as it would take to catch Rose.

I disagree. Jeter is a shell of what he once was, plus he missed too much time recently. Rose was still producing at the age of 40.

Jeter is retiring because he isn't good anymore. What is sad is Jeter starting the All Star game in 2014.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[freakhappy]

Originally Posted by Exhibitman

Jeter would have caught Rose if Jeter had the drive to last in the game for as long as it would take to catch Rose, regardless of where or how he played. Rose would have kept going if he could have found a team to take him. Jeter doesn't have that mentality, so he is going out now as a decent player but on his own terms. More power to him for that. You don't want to see another Rickey Henderson situation, trucking around indie minors teams trying to find any MLB club to take him. That's just sad IMO.

Adam, I respect your opinion, but I don't think it's sad at all the way Henderson left the game. As far as I know, he didn't need the money, but just wanted to play for as long as he could and for the most part, he succeeded. I can see if Henderson just stuck around for money purposes only, but he was a legend that truly loved to play and be around ball players. During his last year or two I remember ESPN showing some highlights of him still playing and being around his minor league teammates and he couldn't have been happier...he is a true idol of mine and his passion for the game is something to be admired. I think a lot of people assume things should happen a certain way and when it doesn't, something is wrong...I just don't believe that is true. I applaud guys like Jamie Moyer, Pete Rose, and Rickey Henderson for trying to play until nothing was left in the tank. True ballplayers if you ask me.

It seems like these days in any sport if you are past your prime, you have a very small leash and will most likely be passed over by a younger player...even if you have some game left in ya. I guess it is what it is.

[I Only Smoke 4 the Cards]

I often think back to Tony Gwynn's farewell tour and shake my head. Teams went the whole nine yards for Ripken but didn't do much for Gwynn.

[I Only Smoke 4 the Cards]

Frank - I never knew that about McGinnity. What an interesting life.

[packs]

I like to think about what Ichiro would have done if he spent his entire career in America. I've got to assume he would have somewhere around 4,500 hits right now playing 30 extra games a year in the majors than in Japan.

[I Only Smoke 4 the Cards]

Originally Posted by packs

I like to think about what Ichiro would have done if he spent his entire career in America. I've got to assume he would have somewhere around 4,500 hits right now playing 30 extra games a year in the majors than in Japan.

I think Ichiro would be the all-time hits leader. When he came to America he was amazing to watch. I cannot imagine what he must have been like years earlier.