Should a post stick to its original topic?

[Buythatcard]

Since this has been mentioned before, I thought it would be interesting to take a poll on this subject.

Many posts start out with one topic which quickly goes off to many other topics.

I personally see nothing wrong with that. Just curious to see what others think.

[HRBAKER]

Bothers me not a bit when it wanders.

[Cardboard Junkie]

I like the unpredictability of some off topic asides. For example, Frank and that Vassar girl.Dave.

[wonkaticket]

For the most part it's fine to wander...in some cases though we should be aware to try and get back to the topic if nothing more than for respect to the OP.

[Buythatcard]

I always find that when it wanders, it opens the door for many new posts.

[Leon]

Originally Posted by wonkaticket

For the most part it's fine to wander...in some cases though we should be aware to try and get back to the topic if nothing more than for respect to the OP.

+1. And I just deleted a duplicate thread, if anyone wondering. Lastly, I voted I don't care but in reality I would, as moderator, prefer they stay on topic...but really, as a member, not a big deal usually. Some of the wandering can be fun. It's freaking baseball cards for crying out loud.

[buymycards]

Did anyone see Miley Cyrus on MTV the other night?

[z28jd]

What does this thread have to do with T206 cards?

[Cardboard Junkie]

Originally Posted by buymycards

Did anyone see Miley Cyrus on MTV the other night?

This...

[iggyman]

I'm happy as a clown and that is the way I voted.

"Lovely day!"

[barrysloate]

Some threads are light and breezy so a little off topic banter shouldn't matter. But on serious threads dealing with big issues, better to stay focused.

[Rich Klein]

The Sunny thread might have stayed on topic without the tag line of the next appearance of 3rd Bass. Of course, that line might have been put in to show where Pete's next public appeareance was. However, once that was put into the thread by the OP -- then the wandering began.

Rich

[HRBAKER]

Originally Posted by buymycards

Did anyone see Miley Cyrus on MTV the other night?

I wasn't surprised, she was born of a mullet.

[Eric72]

Originally Posted by barrysloate

Some threads are light and breezy so a little off topic banter shouldn't matter. But on serious threads dealing with big issues, better to stay focused.

Barry,

Well said...I completely agree.

There certainly are threads which may invite a bit of wandering into the weeds. And these are fine, as far as I am concerned, so long as everyone remains civil.

On the flip side, in-depth discussions regarding topics which are relevant to this hobby, or a segment of it, should absolutely remain focused. The collective knowledge and experience of the board members here is immense. When this is channeled towards something specific, great things can (and often do) happen.

Best Regards,

Eric

[GoldenAge50s]

Originally Posted by barrysloate

Some threads are light and breezy so a little off topic banter shouldn't matter. But on serious threads dealing with big issues, better to stay focused.

My sentiments exactly! I love to sing & dance a bit, but there are certain threads that should stay on topic. (The Nash thread in question & the Bruce Dorskind passing thread are 2 that I think are perfect examples)

[drcy]

The initial Sunny post was about baseball memorabilia and music. In fact the first sentence was about only about a rap concert. There was nothing off topic commenting on the music half, unless the claim is the entire post was off topic.

[benjulmag]

Originally Posted by drcy

The initial Sunny post was about baseball memorabilia and music. In fact the first sentence was about only about a rap concert. There was nothing off topic commenting on the music half, unless the claim is the entire post was off topic.

It strains credulity to believe that Mr.Fraser's intent when initiating his thread was to promote extensive discussion of the rap music genre, and that interpreting the rap reference as anything other than ancillary to his main point -- memorabilia fraud -- reflects a serious misreading of what he was saying.

[toledo_mudhen]

Yeah I saw it... and I gotta say that I felt kinda bad for her, an obvious derailment of the "look at me" generation. It disturbs me that this is what the pop subculture has become. This public display of grotesqueness is a direct result of absolutely zero morals in today's PC society.

[drcy]

I read everything Sunny posted memorabilia-wise and took it to seriously. Even if I didn't comment on it. I don't think what he wrote was lost on anyone, even on those who got into the side rap debate.