Dumb Ebay questions

[Runscott]

I know I'm going to get slapped around for this, but I'm in that sort of mood today

Given the quality of the scans I provide, my feedback and past auction history, this sort of question (actually, a demand) perplexes me. I know it isn't a good selling tactic, but, feeling certain that if he won it he still would't know if it was real or not, I suggested that he collect a different set.

Tell me where you got the card. I'm concerned that it's a repro.

- pjt171

I think I would have been okay with something like the following, which I get a lot of as well, and which I use as an opportunity to educate someone who's obviously new to the '33/'34 Goudeys:

"I see a lot of reproductions on ebay - how do you know it is real?"

[steve B]

Someone actually asked that?

Because you know...
A) A seller wouldn't just lie about where the card came from.
B) A seller couldn't have bought a reprint err....Just about anywhere or any time during the last 30 years.
C) There's some magical place where reprints/scanners/printers/etc just don't exist.

Maybe it's just part of getting old, but I'm becoming more convinced that there are people who simply can't learn anything about anything. And that sadly that's a huge demographic that drives most corporated decisions, leaving me stuck with a choice between products designed for stupid people.

Steve B

[vintagetoppsguy]

I would just turn the question around on him and ask, "What do you see that concerns you it's a repro?"

[glchen]

1933 Goudey Ruth's are reprinted extensively, so this is probably why the potential buyer has that question. Usually, you can say something like it was purchased as part of a lot, and as you can see, I have many other cards with the same characteristic also for sale (or that I have sold in the past). You can also say that you guarantee that the card is authentic if sent to a third party grader. I think buyers are concerned by the stories like you found it in the your grandfather's attic or a flea market, and other nonsense like that.

[Runscott]

Originally Posted by steve B

Someone actually asked that?

Because you know...
A) A seller wouldn't just lie about where the card came from.
B) A seller couldn't have bought a reprint err....Just about anywhere or any time during the last 30 years.
C) There's some magical place where reprints/scanners/printers/etc just don't exist.

Maybe it's just part of getting old, but I'm becoming more convinced that there are people who simply can't learn anything about anything. And that sadly that's a huge demographic that drives most corporated decisions, leaving me stuck with a choice between products designed for stupid people.

Steve B

Steve, I would never insult any new collector who posts here honestly wanting to learn, but here are my thoughts on getting into a new vintage card issue:

• study the hell out of scans, anywhere you can find them, noting differences betwen cards sold by good sellers and those actually labelled as reprints or as 'real-looking'
• ask questions
• Buy a few cheap common semi-beaters from board members (or ebay) and study the hell out of them
• Only after doing the above, if your money is burning a hole in your pocket, buy a more expensive example, but from a reputable source

Too many people, before doing the above, post a link to an expensive card;e.g-1910's Cobb, Wagner, etc, asking us if we think it is real, because they actually plan to buy it as their first card in the set

[Runscott]

David - I like your answer. As a seller, I should always nicely answer questions, no matter how dumb.

This time I didn't


Here's the image I provided:

[nolemmings]

Tell him you got it from Harry's House of Reprints, but that Harry assured you that it had been in his family for generations, having been found in great-grandpa's attic. Then tell him you're married to Morgan Fairchild.

[Runscott]

Originally Posted by nolemmings

Tell him you got it from Harry's House of Reprints, but that Harry assured you that it had been in his family for generations, having been found in great-grandpa's attic. Then tell him you're married to Morgan Fairchild.

Todd, I like that. Maybe I'll write up a pat answer like that for people who I'm absolutely certain aren't really going to bid.

When she made her comeback around 1980, I remember thinking she was really hot for an old woman (she was 30 )

[D. Bergin]

Well, at least you didn't call him a f*#king moron and come here expecting to get pats on the back for it.

[steve B]

Originally Posted by Runscott

Steve, I would never insult any new collector who posts here honestly wanting to learn, but here are my thoughts on getting into a new vintage card issue:

• study the hell out of scans, anywhere you can find them, noting differences betwen cards sold by good sellers and those actually labelled as reprints or as 'real-looking'
• ask questions
• Buy a few cheap common semi-beaters from board members (or ebay) and study the hell out of them
• Only after doing the above, if your money is burning a hole in your pocket, buy a more expensive example, but from a reputable source

Too many people, before doing the above, post a link to an expensive card;e.g-1910's Cobb, Wagner, etc, asking us if we think it is real, because they actually plan to buy it as their first card in the set

Wanting to learn is completely different from thinking that where you got the card is any indicator of wether it's genuine. Maybe if he asked how he could be sure it's real? That would be learning.

My first Goudey came from a yard sale.
My first 48 Bowman Football were found in a trash barrel.
At the second show I went to a dealer was selling Dover reprint T206s with machine rounded corners.

Had I bought one I could legitimately answer that I bought it at a show in 1978. And it would still be fake.

Answering questions, even dumb ones patiently is the way to go, but sometimes when I was selling I had to wait a couple hours before answering.

"Shipping is 1.00 in the US, elsewhere at cost"
"How much to ship to Idaho?"
Yeah, I had to wait a bit.

A batch of movie posters I bought had a bunch from Bang the Drum Slowly. Every time I listed one the same person would ask if it was original or a reprint. I don't actually know the answer, so I'd always reply giving details that might not show in the picture and asking if he knew how to tell. Never replied, never bid.

Steve B

[drc]

I would just answer the question (which was actually not a question). Potential bidders have asked me before, and, while perhaps this guy worded it less than politely, asking where something came from is a fair question. I do appreciate that a seller could be offended by the accusatory, pushy way he said it. I likely would be.

P.s. I know Scott's Goudeys came from a highly reputable and well known source. I wrote the above knowing his answer wouldn't be 'From my grandfather's cabinet.'

[drc]

I remember when I had on ebay am 1880s Tobin Lithograph trade card, and described it as a 'chromolithograph.' An eBayer didn't know what chromolithograph meant and wanted to make sure it wasn't some sort of modern refractor. He question seemed sincere, so I explained that it was just a 19th century time term for colorful lithography. I assured him it wasn't a Topps insert.

[Ronnie73]

I'm not gonna slap you around Scott. I would just answer any question no matter how dumb it is. If the same person continues with the possible fake issue, I would just say maybe this card is not for you. One thing i've learned is if someone asks alot of questions that are already answered in the description and other what if.... questions, usualy its gonna be a problem sale if that person wins. Hope I don't get slapped around now. This place has been a little ruff lately.

[tschock]

Originally Posted by Runscott

Given the quality of the scans I provide, my feedback and past auction history, this sort of question (actually, a demand) perplexes me. I know it isn't a good selling tactic, but, feeling certain that if he won it he still would't know if it was real or not, I suggested that he collect a different set.

Tell me where you got the card. I'm concerned that it's a repro.

It is a very stupid question, no matter how it is worded (IMHO). There are only 2 possibilities here. You know your vintage cards or you don't. The "evidence" (past items, feedback, etc) suggest that you do.

The only other possibility for someone asking this is that they have concerns you are intentionally selling reprints as originals. If that is the case, then I'm certain you would not lie when responding to these types of questions, right? (heavy sarcasm here)