FS: N172 Old Judge Toole SGC 30

[vintagetoppsguy]

For sale 1887 Old Judge Toole SGC 30. Let me preface this by saying I hate those "make offer" listings, but I really have no idea to ask for this card so I am looking for offers. I obtained this card in a trade with a fellow board member about a month ago and I know what I had to give in trade, so I am looking for an offer in that ballpark. I'm not necessarily looking for the best offer, just a fair offer. In other words, I am not going to hold out and wait for the highest offer - I will sell the card to the first offer that I feel is reasonable. Here are the scans. Thanks for looking.

[Donald C. Miller]

I will make it a crisp 100.00 bill for the card.

Don Miller email rellim@abe.midco.net

[felada]

Email sent

[Donald C. Miller]

David,
I believe there has been some confusion about my offer for the card. I guess my wording left some to believe that the card was for sale for 100.00. I have gotten emails offering to buy the card. My original response to your listing was to make an offer of 100.00 for the card. I was hoping you would either accept or reject the offer. 100.00 was not the owner listing a selling price.Hope that cleared up the confusion.

Don Miller

PS My original offer of 100.00 for the card still stands. Rellim@abe.midco.net


























2

[vintagetoppsguy]

Don,

Hello! Thank you for the offer. I obtained the card in a trade with a fellow board member and unfortunately your offer is quite less than what I have into it, so I will have to pass. However, the card has been moved to eBay and you are more than welcome to bid on it. Good luck!

David

http://www.ebay.com/itm/310369839455...84.m1555.l2649

[Runscott]

Originally Posted by vintagetoppsguy

Don,

Hello! Thank you for the offer. I obtained the card in a trade with a fellow board member and unfortunately your offer is quite less than what I have into it, so I will have to pass. However, the card has been moved to eBay and you are more than welcome to bid on it. Good luck!

David

http://www.ebay.com/itm/310369839455...84.m1555.l2649

It sucks not knowing what your stuff is worth

I'm in the same boat with T205's - you can either figure it out and post prices, knowing you're likely to take a hit due to your lack of knowledge, or you can let the market decide for you on ebay. Sounds like you made the right decision.

[Matthew H]

I'd guess it's worth around $200 maybe a little more.