Looking for an ebay seller's point of view--

[dougscats]

I bought this item on ebay:
http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll...K%3AMEWNX%3AIT

It turned out to be a reprint [I compared it to a dozen other real ones I have, and then looked at it under a microscope].
I contacted the seller, who said:

By all means send the card back and you will get a full refund ....no clue that a card in the condition it is in wold be a reproduction ..picked it up from an antique flea market but I do know peole will do anything for a few bucks ....Thanks

- rypper01

I returned it, and he gave me a refund, though not a full refund, as I wound up paying the return shipping.

I don't give negative feedback lightly, so I thought a neutral was in order, with the comment:
Sold reprint as original. Refunded, but I had to pay return shipping.

Ebay asks me to be sure I want to post such neutral/negative feedback. So, before I do: What do you think? Am I being fair? I'd particularly aprreciate a sellers point of view.

Thanks.

Doug