Interesting PSA and Ebay Issue

[JamesGallo]

So often I have talked to a buddy of mine about the "no returns on graded cards" phrase often seen in ebay auctions.

He always was of the mind set that they seller would be forced to take a card back no matter what and that was that.

I always felt that it would be a case by case basis and it would depend on the reason the buyer gave for the return.

Well a situation arose recently where I bought a PSA graded card and wanted to return it. I contacted the seller with no response and so filied my paypal claim.

The card in question in on the right and graded a PSA 10 no less.

http://www.thetoyheaven.com/images/i...cksonfake1.jpg

The problem and reason for the return is the said card is a reprint!!
The PSA 9 is real.

So aside from the fact that PSA graded a reprint and the seller had a no return policy paypal decided in my favor and the card is now on the way back to the seller.

Aside from the said fact that PSA graded a pretty crappie reprint I thought that this was an interesting fact that even with a graded card paypal forced the seller to take the card back.

I thought this would be of some interest for various reasons :-D

James G