Mickey, Duke, and Willie Autograph Opinion

[HankAaron755]

These three autographs are apart of a single piece that I’m looking to purchase. While I feel comfortable with the Mantle autograph, I don’t know much about the Mays or Snider to make an educated opinion. The Snider looks rushed, but I have seen other examples from the big auction sites with a similar form. This is a numbered piece and since this example is on the higher end of the run, possibly that’s why it appears rushed.

Would greatly appreciate any feedback or opinion someone can provide.

[philliesfan]

I am in no way an expert or anything and please do not base your willingness to buy or not based on my opinion, but I think all three are good.

[HankAaron755]

Originally Posted by philliesfan

I am in no way an expert or anything and please do not base your willingness to buy or not based on my opinion, but I think all three are good.

Thanks for your input Robert. This is a signed Ron Lewis piece where Ron signed it himself too. While I have seen others I believe to be apart of this numbered series verified by JSA, the signatures are slightly different. Just one of those situations where you are comfortable with one auto, but don’t know enough about the others to make a decision.

[rand1com]

I personally do not like the Mantle at all but it looks to be a numbered edition that I assume we’re all signed although I do not know that for sure. I would pass if offered to me but it certainly could be good. The Mays looks OK but the Snider also looks off.

[HankAaron755]

Originally Posted by rand1com

I personally do not like the Mantle at all but it looks to be a numbered edition that I assume we’re all signed although I do not know that for sure. I would pass if offered to me but it certainly could be good. The Mays looks OK but the Snider also looks off.

Appreciate the feedback Randy. I’m going to pass on it for now. For taking everything I know about the piece into account, there are just too many question marks for me to make a comfortable purchasing decision.

[Kco]

All 3 are spot on, 100% authentic, nice piece

[HankAaron755]

Originally Posted by Kco

All 3 are spot on, 100% authentic, nice piece

Thanks for the feedback Kevin! This piece recently sold at an auction for $600. Pretty spot on for this type of signed item. I wanted to bid, but just wasn’t confident everything was above board.

[johnts1]

Very nice autos I love the Mays. Very crisp. The Mantle flows as well.