1915 Zeenut Fred McMullen Pop Reports

[ThomasL]

I generally dont care or know a lot about pop reports, but I wanted to research one of my favorite cards the 1915 Zeenut Fred McMullen (sic McMullin). PSA has 3 listed and SGC has 13 listed...I have found pictures of 13 out of the 16.

2 questions: 1. How accurate are the pop reports?; 2. Does anyone happen to have scans/pics of the 3 I am missing...or any raw or others I have missed?

Here is a detailed breakdown of what I have found as far:

1915 Zeenut Fred McMullen Cards

PSA Graded
5 – 44228643 $4,670.40 Leland’s 2019 Fall
1 – 27740463 (hole punch) $4,800 REA 2022 Spring
*Missing PSA ATH -

Note: The 0ct 2018 Cleansweep Auction catalog mentions two PSA grade example sales: PSA 1 on 10-2017 for $5,700, which was the hole punch 27740463 card, and a PSA 2 sale for $7,000. This PSA 2 isn’t listed in PSA’s pop report and I have not been able to find a picture or sale of this card.

SGC Graded
4 – 8543511 $6,600 Heritage Dec 5, 2019
40 (3) – 1277068-001 $7,050 REA 2011 Spring
-3 – 2140007 (same card as SGC 1277068-001 in an updated holder/label
$6,600 REA 2019 Fall
40 (3) – 1277137-144 $4,148 REA 2012 Spring
40 (3) – 8174055-001 (crease) $5,466 Cleansweep Oct 2018
40 (3) – 1370283-018 $4,560 Heritage Dec 13, 2020
2 – 6069233 (water stain on front upper left) $2,940 Love of the Game 2023 Fall
-30 (2) - 1213110-013 – old SGC holder for 6069233
*Missing a SGC 2
20 (1.5) – 8170527-001 (“Rare” on the back) $5,100 REA 2018 Fall
20 (1.5) – 1245643-001 (scuff on left arm) $4,024.88 Mile High June 10, 2010
10 (1) – 1217299-016 (Buck Barker Collection, wrinkled, notes on back)
1 – 4312121 (faded front, scribbles on back) $3,000 REA 2022 Summer

WITH COUPON
20 (1.5) – 1272312-141 (upper left crease) $7,170 Heritage May 17, 2014
*Missing SGC 1