1/1 -- 1/25 Pre-War Items

[LincolnVT]

We all hear about and see the 1/1 and 1/25 modern cards and memorabilia pieces now days at auction and on the internet. Let's see some real pre-war rarities...cards, cabinets, photos and other interesting pre-war gems with a known combined population of less than 25.

[packs]

Good luck finding 25 of these:

[chadeast]

[Casey2296]

1/1's
_

[Leon]

1927 Babe Comes Home card, on card stock.

[the-illini]

one of only 2 I believe

[nat]

Obviously there are probably some raw ones out there, and I don't know SGC's pop, but PSA has graded only five of these Carey type 1s:

[53toppscollector]

I don't have anything super rare. 3 of my T206 Krause portraits have a combined PSA/SGC pop of 20 or less

[BabyRuth]

some obscure items

[glchen]

More obscure ones

[jcmtiger]

Not many of these around, not a card, calendar top.

[mrreality68]

Originally Posted by glchen

More obscure ones

WOW WOW and WOW

Super Nice Ruth Cards and Super Hard to find.

Been hunting for years to find one and you have 3.

Congrats on those

[mrreality68]

Here is a 1 of 1 (at least that is KNOWN)

[vansaad]

Not quite pre-war, but I love this version of Old Gold Robinson. 1/22 combined graded. Great write up on the back.

Jackie Old Gold catching_front.jpg
Jackie Old Gold catching_back.jpg

[rdwyer]

I rather have vintage. Take for example a 1/1 Mike Trout signed card. There are probably 100 if not more other 1/1 cards of Mike Trout.

[Leon]

Originally Posted by mrreality68

Here is a 1 of 1 (at least that is KNOWN)

That's an awesome card, Jeff.
Here is Chief..

[riggs336]

This is the only PSA graded Witmor Eddie Collins and there are only 25 total PSA graded Witmors. So that's rare, right?

[Rhotchkiss]

This is a 1 of 1, and is currently for sale in Memory Lane (sorry for the shameless plug, but it does fit the OPs topic.

[Rhotchkiss]

A few other rarities (from 1 of 1 to less than 10), including a rare side-kick to Jeff's amazing Joe Jax

[brianp-beme]

This Type 2 R308 Tattoo Orbit of Pepper Martin (shown with the smaller R308 as well as the more common and colorful R305 for comparison) only exists as a NFT card.

Brian (NFT = Not For Pterodactyls...because phonetically speaking, they would make a mäk(ə)rē of this card)

[53toppscollector]

That Wagner Harpers Whiskey issue is incredible.

[2dueces]

MrReality. I don’t think that card can be topped.
Congratulations on owning that one.

[peanuts]

Originally Posted by glchen

More obscure ones

WOW. Those are some gorgeous cards. Are there any more to the set?

[oldjudge]

1/1

[tedzan]

Speaking of "1 of 1".......I have four T206's that are unique. Plus, a 1904 team card that appears to be unique.
I acquired these "goodies" over the past 30+ years. I have searched for a 2nd. So far, they still remain unique.


. .



.




The DRUM card of Frank Delahanty in my A - B - C - D connection here is unique.







And, I'll throw into this mix a T206 proof.....unique, or what ? I have searched for another Puttman proof for many years.... to no avail.







Last, but not least....Buffalo Bisons 1904 Team card, which represents a significant piece of BB history. The Bisons of the Eastern League were
considered the "World Champions", as there was no Major League World Series in 1904 (the NY Giants refused to play the Boston Americans).




TED Z

T206 Reference
.

[puckpaul]

Not sure of the pop, but i don’t think there are 25 of them. Pinkerton Wajo

[keating3620]

1\1

[x2drich2000]

Really love the W.W. Smith postcards like Ryan posted. Here's my Wagner and if we're including back variations, my current obsession set.

[WillowGrove]

Great thread!

Kid Nichols portrait cabinet taken by Chickering ca. 1897. Anyone ever see another?

[glchen]

Originally Posted by peanuts

WOW. Those are some gorgeous cards. Are there any more to the set?

Thanks! There are at least 3 more in this set, maybe more. I know the board members have a few of them.

[sb1]

Originally Posted by WillowGrove

Great thread!

Kid Nichols portrait cabinet taken by Chickering ca. 1897. Anyone ever see another?

Yes, I used to have one. I will have to dig out an image but I am pretty sure 1897 was inscribed in the negative and thus on the cabinet. A board member has it now(unless he has moved it).

[Angyale]

I think there are 3 or 4 of the W600s known and a similarly small size handfull of the Toledo Colgans.

Angyale

[mrreality68]

Originally Posted by 2dueces

MrReality. I don’t think that card can be topped.
Congratulations on owning that one.

Appreciated Joe and I enjoy having this card.

But there is a lot of Great Cards that would either top my card or give it a run.

This thread has many great and rare cards showing with more to come

[DeanH3]

Wouldn't surprise me if there are enough raw examples out there to get over 25, but thus far these two have a combined pop less than 25.

[molenick]

My guess is that there are not 25 known of any specific Pinkerton cabinet.

[Leon]

Type card collectors have an unfair advantage in this thread. I paid less the second time I bought this one LOL

[jcc6252]

Living in Indy, I bought it strictly for the back. 1 of 2 graded, according to the combined pop reports.

[x2drich2000]

Originally Posted by Leon

Type card collectors have an unfair advantage in this thread. I paid less the second time I bought this one LOL

As would 19th Century collectors.

[AMPduppp]

Pop 21 between SGC and PSA, but also the only card released for Walt "Smoke" Justis

[fkm_bky]

Some great cards here!

Soon to be slabbed by SGC, but there are only 7 graded of the Huggins Port, Tolstoi reverse T206.

PSA - 4
SGC - 2
BVG - 1

Bill

[milkit1]

Black factory 30 Evers/Chance
Blank back Mordecai Brown M116

t202 evers chance black 50 front.jpg

t202 evers chance black 50 back.jpg

brown fronts.jpg

brown backs.jpg

[packs]

Nice M116. I've got an oddity of my own. Have seen some people suggest they're cut from a poster, but there are at least two Walter Johnson no names known and my card is the same stock as the regular issues:

[chadeast]

Originally Posted by puckpaul

Not sure of the pop, but i don’t think there are 25 of them. Pinkerton Wajo

Wow! This Big Train collector kneels before its greatness.

[Leon]

Originally Posted by packs

Nice M116. I've got an oddity of my own. Have seen some people suggest they're cut from a poster, but there are at least two Walter Johnson no names known and my card is the same stock as the regular issues:

SO there is another of these floating around? Learn something new everyday. I thought there was only one large grouping of them known.

[ValKehl]

This 1916 D352 Morehouse Baking of WaJo is a 1 of 1 per the pop reports (no graded examples).

Ethan, please don't take this as a criticism of your post, but all or almost all of the individual cards in very many (if not most) of the pre-War sets have less than 25 examples known to exist. My pre-War favorites are the real-photo, black & white card sets from 1916, 1917 and 1920-22 with a plethora of advertising backs; there are less than 25 examples known of every card in most of these sets. IMHO, for a pre-War card to be considered truly rare there should be less than 5 examples known to exist.

[Touch'EmAll]

Really like this one

[Rhotchkiss]

Another round Wagner, and a square one

[brianp-beme]

Here is an irregularly shaped Orange Border Wagner.

Brian

[Casey2296]

I think there's about 12 of these out there.
_

[mrreality68]

Here is another Joe Jackson with a 1 of 1 (known) advertising back