1916 & 1917 Zeenut

[lbailey]

Hey all,

I posted on here earlier this week asking for help figuring out a price on a 1916 Frank Chance Zeenut. I know have the pictures as well as the other 6 I would like to acquire. Finding prices is very hard. Any help would be greatly appreciated.

[Leon]

Forgetting the Chance I would guesstimate 450-650 each. But those are just guesses. Good luck.

[lbailey]

Originally Posted by Leon

Forgetting the Chance I would guesstimate 450-650 each. But those are just guesses. Good luck.

Do you really own the forum?

[Leon]

Originally Posted by lbailey

Do you really own the forum?

Yes. Someone has to.

[oldjudge]

Why to cards with coupons say hand cut on the slab?

[asphaltman]

Originally Posted by oldjudge

Why to cards with coupons say hand cut on the slab?

I have a couple of 16's that say the same thing. I'm not sure why PSA started labeling like that. And from what I can tell it's just with the 16's so far.

[Fred]

Originally Posted by oldjudge

Why to cards with coupons say hand cut on the slab?

Darn good question - those are awesome. Probably worth about $40 a piece. I'd be willing to give you $50 a piece. Send me your paypal address....

Those are really nice. As I was scrolling down the pictures I was waiting to see a Claxton and crap my pants. Thank you for not having the Claxton else it would have been embarrassing trying to explain why I crapped my pants....

Edited to add - those are condition rarities.

[asphaltman]

Originally Posted by Fred

Darn good question - those are awesome. Probably worth about $40 a piece. I'd be willing to give you $50 a piece. Send me your paypal address....

Those are really nice. As I was scrolling down the pictures I was waiting to see a Claxton and crap my pants. Thank you for not having the Claxton else it would have been embarrassing trying to explain why I crapped my pants....

Edited to add - those are condition rarities.

Looking at the one I added, serial numbers are all right there together with the other 1916's designated with the hand cut label. So obviously all from the same submission, and most likely, find.

[Kenny Cole]

The last 1916 Zeenut Chance that VCP lists in anything remotely similar to the condition of this one was a SGC 70 (5.5) without tab that sold for $1,645 in 2011. I would probably use a 4X multiplier for one with a tab, although there are others who have far more experience with this set than I do.

[asphaltman]

Originally Posted by Kenny Cole

The last 1916 Zeenut Chance that VCP lists in anything remotely similar to the condition of this one was a SGC 70 (5.5) without tab that sold for $1,645 in 2011. I would probably use a 4X multiplier for one with a tab, although there are others who have far more experience with this set than I do.

Just my guess, in the right auction house that Chance with the tab would be $7500-$10,000

[steve B]

Originally Posted by oldjudge

Why to cards with coupons say hand cut on the slab?

Since they can't detect trimming they're phasing in the "handcut" designation on all cards.

[lbailey]

Originally Posted by steve B

Since they can't detect trimming they're phasing in the "handcut" designation on all cards.

Does a handcut on the memo even effect value on these?

[Exhibitman]

Originally Posted by steve B

Since they can't detect trimming they're phasing in the "handcut" designation on all cards.

[Leon]

The hand cut designation is a complete joke. I think the tpg's have their heads up their behinds assessing strip cards. Those cards are no more hand cut than a factory cut '72 Topps. They got it wrong. Period.
They shouldn't affect value as collectors should know the tpg is wrong.