Looking to invest in a George Springer card...

[AstroJake09]

Hi all,

I am curious about investing in a George Springer card from 2010 and these are my two options.

1.) 2010 Team USA card BGS 10, the POP report lists it as the only one and the highest graded example of that card. Price is $49 dollars.

2.) 2010 Team USA card, auto redemption /99. Prices are high for this card but I can get it for $220 ungraded.

[D.P.Johnson]

Get both of them.

[bnorth]

Originally Posted by D.P.Johnson

Get both of them.

+1 How could you not make $ at those prices.

[AstroJake09]

Originally Posted by bnorth

+1 How could you not make $ at those prices.

I always grapple with the possible return on my investment in the future, or therefore lackoff as a college student. Can I get the Bowman auto? The answer is yes. I just want to make sure it would be a wise investment and that is always tricky.

[bigfanNY]

I like USA cards but the market is much more consistant with Bowman cards than these. Most consider his 2011 Bowman chrome issue his first card. So that is the card that if Springer continues to have a hall of fame career should benifit the most. But understand it will fluctuate with his performance like many modern cards. But you should be able to get get a nice graded example for around $175.

[AstroJake09]

Originally Posted by bigfanNY

I like USA cards but the market is much more consistant with Bowman cards than these. Most consider his 2011 Bowman chrome issue his first card. So that is the card that if Springer continues to have a hall of fame career should benifit the most. But understand it will fluctuate with his performance like many modern cards. But you should be able to get get a nice graded example for around $175.

The 2010 auto redemption has the 1st Bowman Chrome logo on it. Would that one carry a premium over the 2011 one? Is $220 a fair price? I like the 2010 auto because it was also his first printed card.

[BeanTown]

Originally Posted by D.P.Johnson

Get both of them.

+1 and add a minor league card from the stadium to the mix! Thank me later

[Jason19th]

I really don’t see the long term value of Springer. He is a very good player but he is turning 30 soon and he has 706 career hits. He nowhere near hall of fame pace. He just a good player who has the same skill set as a bunch of guys who are now nothing but minor stars in the guide. Is he as good as guys like George Foster, Wally Post, John Mayberry. Kirk Gibson. How much are those cards going for.

[bigfanNY]

Yes the 2010 is his first card But more people collect regular Bowman rookies than USA cards look how little a Bryce Harper 2009 USA card sells for vs his 2010 bowman (even before the USA card was counterfeit) up to you collect what you like is First rule. But money is always a thing and his 2011 looks like the card. Also the 2010 is a sticker auto that also takes some folks out of the mix. So 2011 better market and on card auto. BUT...collect what you like ... best advice I ever got ..good luck.Jonathan

[commishbob]

I like Springer. I'm happy that I get to see him play as often as I do. But before you 'invest' in him consider his career trajectory.

These are his 'similarity scores' from Baseball-Reference.


Similar Batters

Yasiel Puig (949.9)
Walt Moryn (943.1)
Kal Daniels (937.0)
Craig Wilson (936.1)
Kevin Mench (934.2)
Pat Mullin (928.6)
Morgan Ensberg (927.7)
Mike Morse (927.2)
Bob Cerv (926.5)
Geronimo Berroa (926.4)

Similar Batters through 28

Wally Post (954.0)
Bobby Higginson (950.0)
Jay Buhner (943.6)
Kirk Gibson (943.4)
Jose Cruz (941.8)
Curtis Granderson (940.3)
David Justice (940.0)
Jay Gibbons (939.7)
Bob Allison (939.2)
Reggie Sanders (937.5)

Most Similar by Ages

25 Drew Stubbs (973.2)
26 Willie Kirkland (973.5)
27 Willie Kirkland (956.8)
28 Wally Post (954.0)

[Duluth Eskimo]

Jake,
I am going to say something that a lot of people are thinking, but haven’t said. You keep posting in the “Vintage Sports Memorabilia” forum topics about new cards. Please post those in the “Post War” cars section. Both Springer and Joe Mauer don’t belong here. Thanks

[AstroJake09]

Originally Posted by bigfanNY

Yes the 2010 is his first card But more people collect regular Bowman rookies than USA cards look how little a Bryce Harper 2009 USA card sells for vs his 2010 bowman (even before the USA card was counterfeit) up to you collect what you like is First rule. But money is always a thing and his 2011 looks like the card. Also the 2010 is a sticker auto that also takes some folks out of the mix. So 2011 better market and on card auto. BUT...collect what you like ... best advice I ever got ..good luck.Jonathan

Thinking about it, it actually makes sense. George was drafted in 2011 so that card means more to his professional career, it is a good looking card too. I see one on eBay, graded at 9.5 with a 9 auto under $30 with less than a day till it sells. I'll try my luck with that one.

[AstroJake09]

Originally Posted by Duluth Eskimo

Jake,
I am going to say something that a lot of people are thinking, but haven’t said. You keep posting in the “Vintage Sports Memorabilia” forum topics about new cards. Please post those in the “Post War” cars section. Both Springer and Joe Mauer don’t belong here. Thanks

My bad, I see that now. Thanks for the heads up.

[AstroJake09]

I am also wondering about his non-auto card of the same 2011 Bowman set? Is that worth anything? I can find a nice copy that is graded for a fraction of the price.

[bnorth]

Originally Posted by AstroJake09

I am also wondering about his non-auto card of the same 2011 Bowman set? Is that worth anything? I can find a nice copy that is graded for a fraction of the price.

Are you looking for a very short term flip? There is no way this card will be worth more long term. He is too old and his career #s suck. Honestly these cards will be in the bargain bins in the not too distant future.

Even short term it is a HUGE risk when you consider it has to increase in value just to break even with the selling/shipping fees.

[AstroJake09]

Originally Posted by bnorth

Are you looking for a very short term flip? There is no way this card will be worth more long term. He is too old and his career #s suck. Honestly these cards will be in the bargain bins in the not too distant future.

Even short term it is a HUGE risk when you consider it has to increase in value just to break even with the selling/shipping fees.

I'm not looking to flip the cards. George is my favorite active player. I met him again at the Astros Rockies game last night after meeting him two other times, I gave him a drawing I did and he signed my ball I brought with, telling me thank you. He's a stand-out guy and my personal favorite in the game! I just like the "first cards" of certain guys, Griffey Jr., Mauer, Biggio, Springer... those are the cards that interest me.

Here's the drawing I gave to Georgie,

[bnorth]

Originally Posted by AstroJake09

I'm not looking to flip the cards. George is my favorite active player. I met him again at the Astros Rockies game last night after meeting him two other times, I gave him a drawing I did and he signed my ball I brought with, telling me thank you. He's a stand-out guy and my personal favorite in the game! I just like the "first cards" of certain guys, Griffey Jr., Mauer, Biggio, Springer... those are the cards that interest me.

Here's the drawing I gave to Georgie,

Your thread title says INVEST. If he is a favorite player buy what you like. I have bought many items of my favorite player that I knew would lose value.

[Jim65]

Originally Posted by AstroJake09

My bad, I see that now. Thanks for the heads up.

I'm not suggesting you leave here but if you want advice about modern cards, you should join Blowout if you haven't already.

[Leon]

Originally Posted by AstroJake09

My bad, I see that now. Thanks for the heads up.

Move it for you. Please be careful where you post in the future. If you see you posted in the wrong spot just PM me, or another moderator, and we can move it. Thanks
ps...no idea who this player is. I have no desire to watch current MLB....

[Peter_Spaeth]

George Springer is not an investment. Just buy a card of him you like. Personally I would go with a real rookie card not a pre rookie.

[KCRfan1]

I have to agree with some of the other comments that Springer, while a good player, is not an investment and certainly not HoF.

This is a player that has led the league in games played, plate appearances, and caught stealing......that's it. Best MVP finish is 13th.

A minor league card would be fun and stick to his true rookie cards. Springer has lots of cards to choose from that are a nice addition to a collection.

There's no need to spend the money for a "10" when you can get nice 9's and 8's at a fraction of the price. Or go ungraded and save even more.