Browning Old Judge on Ebay

[oldjudge]

Congratulations to whoever won the Old Judge Pete Browning on Ebay tonight. This is a scarce card of a very popular player, a card I haven’t seen come to market in quite a few years.

[Steve D]

I've had Browning on my wantlist for years; this was the first one I've ever seen for sale. I had zero chance at it though

I thought it interesting that it was being sold by a general antique dealer in Truckee (Lake Tahoe) California. It looks like someone came in to them with a group of Old Judges, as the seller had several others ending tonight.


Steve

[bigfish]

That was a score! Congrats to the winner.

[trdcrdkid]

I noticed the Browning and would have loved to get it, but the price quickly got too rich for my blood. I did win one OJ from the same seller, this John Barnes, St. Paul manager, with a great, sharp image.

[oldjudge]

David—Beautiful image. Congratulations!

[Bored5000]

Originally Posted by trdcrdkid

I noticed the Browning and would have loved to get it, but the price quickly got too rich for my blood. I did win one OJ from the same seller, this John Barnes, St. Paul manager, with a great, sharp image.

That is great image clarity for an Old Judge card. Congrats on the purchase.

[Steve D]

I love the top hat and pocket watch!


Steve

[Huysmans]

Originally Posted by Steve D

I love the top hat and pocket watch!


Steve

When gentlemen were gentlemen.

[rjackson44]

Gorgeous cards

[judsonhamlin]

That was a nice grouping of cards - The Annis, Worcester had an interesting 'miscut' that was a cool flaw in the reproduction process and that Barkley portrait is, I think, fairly tough.

[scooter729]

I missed the auction and now can't find the listing for the Browning - could someone share a link as I'd like to see it - thanks!

[judsonhamlin]

Can't seem to paste the link here but if you search truckeeantiques completed items it should pop up.,
I would also expect more Old Judges from them since this group was only A-G. H to Z could be interesting.

[Leon]

Here ya go

https://www.ebay.com/itm/1887-N172-O...p2047675.l2557

Originally Posted by judsonhamlin

Can't seem to paste the link here but if you search truckeeantiques completed items it should pop up.,
I would also expect more Old Judges from them since this group was only A-G. H to Z could be interesting.

[Piratedogcardshows]

Originally Posted by judsonhamlin

Can't seem to paste the link here but if you search truckeeantiques completed items it should pop up.,
I would also expect more Old Judges from them since this group was only A-G. H to Z could be interesting.

Good catch on the A-G listing detail. He may yet list the Old Judge at the top of my want list!

[judsonhamlin]

Richmond native and veteran of the 1884 Virginians, Billy Nash?

[pete zouras]

They will not be listing anymore OJs. These were all they were able to win at an estate auction (about half). Glad I was able to pick up one.

[judsonhamlin]

Nuts.

[oldjudge]

Maybe the other half will come to market via a different seller.

[pete zouras]

https://witherells.com/lot/1887-n172...od-2-5-3951831

[Piratedogcardshows]

Originally Posted by judsonhamlin

Richmond native and veteran of the 1884 Virginians, Billy Nash?

Who lol?

[oldjudge]

Originally Posted by pete zouras

https://witherells.com/lot/1887-n172...od-2-5-3951831

He certainly did. If the auction house had done a little leg work they could have found this site and posted about the Old Judge group. Pity for the consignor.

[packs]

I thought it went cheap. I figured it would end around 6K.

[oldjudge]

It’s been so long since a copy has come to market that I had no idea what to expect. As I told a friend, I would not have been surprised if it went for $2,500, and I would not have been surprised if it went for $10,000.

[trdcrdkid]

Originally Posted by oldjudge

He certainly did. If the auction house had done a little leg work they could have found this site and posted about the Old Judge group. Pity for the consignor.

All of those OJs went incredibly cheap, below even the lowball estimates made by the auction house. The miscut Annis went for $60 (estimate $100-$250), the Gypsy Queen Carroll went for $387 (estimate $100-$250), Buck Ewing and Dan Brouthers for $714 and $208 respectively (estimates $250-$500, the same as commons), the Barkley portrait for $107 (estimate $250-$500). Somebody at that auction house had no clue what they were doing and no clue what they had.

https://witherells.com/auction/mantu...search=display

[oldjudge]

It is not a sin that a general auction house might not know about a particular card issue. What is horrible is if they don’t educate themselves before auctioning the items. Contrast this with the great job that Phillip Weiss did for his consignor with the Long Island Old Judge cabinet find.

[Steve D]

Originally Posted by pete zouras

https://witherells.com/lot/1887-n172...od-2-5-3951831

Is that correct; that the Browning went for only $238 on June 5th?


Steve

[oldjudge]

Sure appears that way

[tennisguy]

Originally Posted by judsonhamlin

That was a nice grouping of cards - The Annis, Worcester had an interesting 'miscut' that was a cool flaw in the reproduction process and that Barkley portrait is, I think, fairly tough.

I like the Barkley Portrait. I have always liked that OJ portrait card! Unfortunately, came up short. Is the Barkley Portrait considered tough? I know there is two versions of his Portrait image. Sold for just under $400 PSA 2? High??

[oldjudge]

I think in that condition the portrait price was on the low side of fair.

[tennisguy]

Originally Posted by oldjudge

I think in that condition the portrait price was on the low side of fair.

Is the Barkley a tough portrait to obtain compared to other portraits in the OJ set? (Excluding the spotted tie subset)

[oldjudge]

Kind of in the middle. Healey, Wright Pose 2, the McCormick portraits, and McGreachery (Deacon White) for example are all a lot tougher.

[tennisguy]

Does anyone know where this grouping originated from?