Storing 33 Goudey

[Cmvorce]

What do you all use to encase your ungraded 33 Goudeys? I like the 1-screw vintage card holders that Pro Mold has for Bowman and 52-56 Topps but does anything like this exist for Goudey cards? I hate the way they look in standard size toploaders.

[tiger8mush]

binder

[brianp-beme]

I store mine helically, like the image below.

Actually, I am a Card Savers 2 type of fellow.

Brian

[deadballera]

Brian going commando with his Goudey's

[conor912]

Originally Posted by Cmvorce

What do you all use to encase your ungraded 33 Goudeys? I like the 1-screw vintage card holders that Pro Mold has for Bowman and 52-56 Topps but does anything like this exist for Goudey cards? I hate the way they look in standard size toploaders.

What, exactly, offends you about the toploader look?

[Cmvorce]

Brian, love the stack!

Conor, regarding top loaders for Goudeys, I just don’t like all the extra space. It’s a very petty thing, I know.

I wish they made recessed screw downs for Goudey.

[perezfan]

Same here...

Or the One Touch magnetized holders would be equally welcomed. Can't believe there is still nothing on the market for Goudeys.

[FrankWakefield]

I like the stack. Mine are currently loose, in a card box that I got from Lew Lipset about 25 years ago. They used to be in 9 pocket sheets in a ring binder.

Great pictures, guys!

[conor912]

I hear you on the extra space, though it’s really just at the top. Side to side they’re only 1/8” narrower than a modern card. Have you though about mylar? Not quite the rigidity of a toplaoder, but 4 mil isnt bad, plus you can cut the top to size.

[drcy]

I collect my Goudeys raw. Except in winter when I put on a robe.

[hcv123]

Originally Posted by brianp-beme

I store mine helically, like the image below.

Actually, I am a Card Savers 2 type of fellow.

Brian

It's baseball card Jenga!

[brianp-beme]

Originally Posted by drcy

I collect my Goudeys raw. Except in winter when I put on a robe.

My best advice, whether raw or robed, is to be barefoot. You are more likely to
sneak up on an unsuspecting Goudey that way.


Brian (thanks for all the stacked compliments guys!)

[LuckyLarry]

mylar sleeves from http://tcverify.com

I love this. Old school collecting with fancy handmade dividers even. Great thread and pics. For the first time feel like I belong.

[Cmvorce]

Thanks for the tips on the Mylar sleeves, guys. I hadn’t thought of that.

[Exhibitman]

Originally Posted by LuckyLarry

mylar sleeves from http://tcverify.com

Me too. Then into 4 pocket pages in an album.

[obiwan1129]

I'm really into putting things into the binders these days. I really want to be able to open it up and look at the cards from time to time. Does anyone have strong feelings on laying the binders flat or up, vertically like on a book shelf?

[Cmvorce]

Originally Posted by obiwan1129

I'm really into putting things into the binders these days. I really want to be able to open it up and look at the cards from time to time. Does anyone have strong feelings on laying the binders flat or up, vertically like on a book shelf?

I’ve heard it’s best to store the binder with the ring at the top so the pages are dangling. That supposedly prevents damage to the cards closest to the ring. But I don’t know how true or necessary that is.

[NonSportDaniel]

This is how I store my binders. Hanging from the spines so that the pages hang down with the force away from the rings. It also lets me lock the file cabinet with the binders safely inside.

[icollectDCsports]

Originally Posted by obiwan1129

I'm really into putting things into the binders these days. I really want to be able to open it up and look at the cards from time to time. Does anyone have strong feelings on laying the binders flat or up, vertically like on a book shelf?

If you place a binder on a shelf vertically, as you would a book, there is a risk that the weight of the pages will pull the back end down with binder opening up slightly and the pages contacting the shelf, leading to curling at the bottom of the pages -- and possibly the cards in the bottom slots. You can counter this by ensuring the front and back covers are tightly pressed against the pages or by using binder slip cases. The binder and slip case combinations sold by archival storage companies are very nice but also pricey. However, considering the value of what they're protecting, you might find them to be worth it.

[ALBB]

Cant beat the stack up !

[conor912]

I agree that binders can be a little scary with the sagging, so I had these binders custom made. The pages fit toploaders so even if the pages themselves sag, the card are protected. I built this storage unit for the binders that fits them snugly, so they don't sag either way.

[Cmvorce]

Originally Posted by conor912

I agree that binders can be a little scary with the sagging, so I had these binders custom made. The pages fit toploaders so even if the pages themselves sag, the card are protected. I built this storage unit for the binders that fits them snugly, so they don't sag either way.

Nice set up!

[icollectDCsports]

Originally Posted by conor912

I agree that binders can be a little scary with the sagging, so I had these binders custom made. The pages fit toploaders so even if the pages themselves sag, the card are protected. I built this storage unit for the binders that fits them snugly, so they don't sag either way.

Very well done! Like the finger notches to aid in grabbing the binders for removal.

[ASF123]

Originally Posted by conor912

I agree that binders can be a little scary with the sagging, so I had these binders custom made. The pages fit toploaders so even if the pages themselves sag, the card are protected. I built this storage unit for the binders that fits them snugly, so they don't sag either way.

Nice - who made the binders? They look like the same concept as these - https://toploaderbinder.com - but were they less expensive ($100 for 2 binders/80 pages)?

[conor912]

Originally Posted by ASF123

Nice - who made the binders? They look like the same concept as these - https://toploaderbinder.com - but were they less expensive ($100 for 2 binders/80 pages)?

Thanks, guys. I’m really happy with them. I actually used the pages from this company. I wanted nicer binders than they had though, so I contacted a leather binder company and had them make me these. They were expensive as far as binders go, but storage and presentation are important to me, so it was worth it.

[slantycouch]

Originally Posted by conor912

Thanks, guys. I’m really happy with them. I actually used the pages from this company. I wanted nicer binders than they had though, so I contacted a leather binder company and had them make me these. They were expensive as far as binders go, but storage and presentation are important to me, so it was worth it.

Love the setup, Conor. Looks great.

But WHY did you have to do this to me? After seeing your setup I clearly need those sleeves but agree that their binders just aren't... right. Looks like I'll be dumping funds into custom binders, too.

[obiwan1129]

This is why I come here. I love some of the set ups you guys have used and feel like I might have to up my game a bit. Thanks for the ideas.

[conor912]

Originally Posted by slantycouch

Love the setup, Conor. Looks great.

But WHY did you have to do this to me? After seeing your setup I clearly need those sleeves but agree that their binders just aren't... right. Looks like I'll be dumping funds into custom binders, too.

Thanks, Chris! Some people think I go over the top on storage, but I don't know anyone who would put a Picasso in a $5 frame, and I don't see how a nice set in a cheap vinyl binder is any different.

[obiwan1129]

Just following up, found some of these on Amazon for ~$43/ea. Made by a company called Lighthouse.

https://www.lighthouse.us/vario-g-pa...mechanism.html

Bought one to check it out and liked it, So I bought a couple more. I used regular Ultra Pro pages with the binders.

I liked these because they had the slipcases with them so I can store them with the pages dangling on a bookshelf. The engineer in me is now wondering if I need to work up some sort of metal grommet on the page holes.

I'm also ready to make up some nice wood bookends to keep them from getting knocked over by a random child or household pet.

[Cmvorce]

John, excited to see this thread back at the top (one of my favorite discussions). Those binders look sweet. Are they big enough to fit complete sets from the 60s and 70s?

[edjs]

None of you guys use a rubber band and cigar box? Pure OG.

[obiwan1129]

Originally Posted by Cmvorce

John, excited to see this thread back at the top (one of my favorite discussions). Those binders look sweet. Are they big enough to fit complete sets from the 60s and 70s?

Not sure, I've pulled together some team sets, etc no full sets in the binder itself. I bought 4 of them, I wasn't trying to over pack them. It is just a nice way to have them all sorted and organized.

I measured the ring itself to be 2 1/4".

[toledo_mudhen]

Originally Posted by obiwan1129

I'm also ready to make up some nice wood bookends to keep them from getting knocked over by a random child or household pet.

Random Children - They are the worst (and everything they do gets blamed on the Dog)

[Cmvorce]

Originally Posted by obiwan1129

Just following up, found some of these on Amazon for ~$43/ea. Made by a company called Lighthouse.

https://www.lighthouse.us/vario-g-pa...mechanism.html

Bought one to check it out and liked it, So I bought a couple more. I used regular Ultra Pro pages with the binders.

I liked these because they had the slipcases with them so I can store them with the pages dangling on a bookshelf. The engineer in me is now wondering if I need to work up some sort of metal grommet on the page holes.

I'm also ready to make up some nice wood bookends to keep them from getting knocked over by a random child or household pet.

John, I ordered one of the lighthouse vario binder / slipcase combo for the 52 Topps set I'm working on. Love it. Thanks for the recommendation.