T205 error by PSA and Probstein

[ctownboy]

Did anyone else see this error in a listing on eBay? In looking at my T205 cards to see if I had a newly found Archer "variation" I saw that I had a Jimmy Collins card that I forgot about.

In looking at listings on eBay to see what graded Jimmy Collins cards are selling for (all of my cards are ungraded) I saw this listing. The card is of Eddie Collins but both PSA and Probstein have it as Jimmy Collins.

How could they BOTH miss it and was the price paid what a Jimmy Collins would normally sell for, an Eddie Collins or do both players sell for about the same?

David

eBay listing 382315030423

[oldjudge]

LOL, do you think Probstein knows the difference between Jimmy Collins, Eddie Collins, or Landon Collins who plays for the Giants? Shame on PSA though.

[Leon]

Eddie, Jimmy....not much of a difference. Card went for about where it should have. Jimmy might have actually brought a little more being a Minor Leaguer.... Had they bothered to read the back it would have corrected them.

https://www.ebay.com/itm/T205-Gold-B...p2047675.l2557

.

[Aquarian Sports Cards]

Someone got a sweet deal at $153 for a PSA 4. Don't understand how PSA can mess this up, especially since there are two poses of the Eddie Collins Mouth Closed and Mouth Open. I guess they thought this was the rare Jimmy Collins Major League Portrait appearing on a team he played for two years before the set was released variation...

Did start me thinking though. Wonder if Eddie Collins has the highest career batting average to never win a batting title? Be easy enough to check I guess, but I'm lazy

[rats60]

Originally Posted by Aquarian Sports Cards

Someone got a sweet deal at $153 for a PSA 4. Don't understand how PSA can mess this up, especially since there are two poses of the Eddie Collins Mouth Closed and Mouth Open. I guess they thought this was the rare Jimmy Collins Major League Portrait appearing on a team he played for two years before the set was released variation...

Did start me thinking though. Wonder if Eddie Collins has the highest career batting average to never win a batting title? Be easy enough to check I guess, but I'm lazy

Joe Jackson has the 3rd highest lifetime batting average, but never won a batting title. Finished 2nd 3 times, 3rd twice and 4th twice.

[Aquarian Sports Cards]

Originally Posted by rats60

Joe Jackson has the 3rd highest lifetime batting average, but never won a batting title. Finished 2nd 3 times, 3rd twice and 4th twice.

OK smarty pants lol.

[Sean]

Originally Posted by rats60

Joe Jackson has the 3rd highest lifetime batting average, but never won a batting title. Finished 2nd 3 times, 3rd twice and 4th twice.

... including the year he hit .408, and Cobb hit .420.

[Misunderestimated]

At this grade Jimmy would go for quite a bit more -- at PSA 6 or 7 the difference would be very very significant ...
FYI:
A PSA 4 Eddie Collins (closed mouth -- the more common) goes for around $225
A PSA 4 Jimmy Collins goes for about $400 kinda a tough card -- a very cool card by the way that shows him batting as a Minor Leaguer with Providence (now star players from the Majors retire and own teams like Jeter)
The buyer of this one will have to deal with the hassle of getting it correctly holdered which is "free" (except for postage)....
I view Probstein as a very efficient "clearing house" and he sold a PSA holder that said "T205 Jimmy Collins PSA 4 VG-EX".... I'm not sure I expect much more (low expectations I know). PSA is the party at fault .... I wonder about the consignor to Probstein did he know or care?

[pokerplyr80]

Yea I don't really place much blame on probstein for this one. As big as the operation is I wouldn't be surprised if he pays someone to scan the images and create the listings. You can't expect them to research every card and make sure the correct player is listed on the flip.

[Leon]

Originally Posted by pokerplyr80

Yea I don't really place mich blame on probation for this one. As big as the operation is I wouldn't be surprised if he pays someone to scan the images and create the listings. You can't expect them to research every card and make sure the correct player is listed on the flip.

Probation? What's on your mind?

.

[pokerplyr80]

Originally Posted by Leon

Probation? What's on your mind?

.

Lol, auto correct.