E92 Seigle - Is this one authentic?

[timkb]

I compared a few examples and this card looks authentic but I am still learning.

http://www.ebay.com/itm/E92-SEIGLE-D...YAAOSwSclXLN96

Here is one example I used for comparison:

http://www.ebay.com/itm/1909-E92-Nad...wAAOSwvzRX0uav



What do the experts think?

Thanks in advance for all your help!

[edhans]

Authentic.

[brianp-beme]

Nice original card, substantially overpriced.

Brian

[timkb]

Originally Posted by brianp-beme

Nice original card, substantially overpriced.

Brian

You believe it's overpriced at $129.00?

Sent from my Pixel XL using Tapatalk

[x2drich2000]

Originally Posted by timkb

You believe it's overpriced at $129.00?

Sent from my Pixel XL using Tapatalk

I also think it is overpriced. If you search auctions, you will probably be able to find a Dockman in a 2 and maybe even a 3 for less than $100. You could probably find a crofts cocoa or candy in 3 for $150 or so. The downfall is you will need to search for one as they won't be available everyday at that price.

DJ

[timkb]

Thank you all for the suggestions, super helpful!

Sent from my Pixel XL using Tapatalk

[VintageBen]

Originally Posted by x2drich2000

I also think it is overpriced. If you search auctions, you will probably be able to find a Dockman in a 2 and maybe even a 3 for less than $100. You could probably find a crofts cocoa or candy in 3 for $150 or so. The downfall is you will need to search for one as they won't be available everyday at that price.

DJ

http://www.ebay.com/itm/SGC-GRADED-2...kAAOSwrhBZAp2k

here's a sgc 2 crofts candy.. make an offer and see what they say. at least you will know its an authentic card

[Chris-Counts]

Maybe because it's a really cool horizontal pose, but this one always seems to be priced fairly high. I've been looking for a nice one at a good price for years.

[x2drich2000]

Originally Posted by VintageBen

http://www.ebay.com/itm/SGC-GRADED-2...kAAOSwrhBZAp2k

here's a sgc 2 crofts candy.. make an offer and see what they say. at least you will know its an authentic card

Good Morning Ben,

Not really sure what point you are making, but I'm going to assume you think my estimates are off. The card linked is an e101, not an e92 crofts candy or cocoa. As I stated, you're not going to find a crofts everyday because the card is not always available, at least not from a seller who is not overpricing the card. Any one can ask what they want for the card, it doesn't mean there is a buyer at that price.

As far as the Seigle is concerned, below are a few completed sales for the different e92 backs within the past few years.

Dockman
$126 psa 4 (2014)

$146 psa 4 (2016)

$47 SGC 30 (2013)


Cocoa
$120 PSA 2 (2017)

$168 PSA 2 (2017 - Same as the other cocoa card)


Candy (edited to add: Seigle is one of the lowest pop croft candy cards and this is the highest graded. This is also the only sale I could find.)
$267 psa 3 (2017)


Nadja
$189 SGC 10 (2014 - same card listed in the original comparison - I was the under bidder)

$48 sgc 10 beater (2013 - i won)

[ronniehatesjazz]

There's a pretty decent psa2 right now for $89/OBO on eBay right now.