Jewish Players premium?

[JamesGallo]

So I recently had an online dealer tell me that a Benny Kauff was not a common because he was Jewish. Both registries value him as a common. Although I have known a few players like Marsans and Koufax where people attach Jewish to the player, I can't say I have ever had someone hype a card because of a players religion. I consider myself pretty well versed in baseball and I can't ever recall there being any discrimination against Jews. Am I wrong about this? Should a common be more then a common because of their religion. Am I missing something?

James G

[ullmandds]

probably worth less to a palestinian!

[h2oya311]

Benny Kauff does usually command a premium, but he was not Jewish, despite what some may think. Kauff was banned from baseball by Landis because of alleged auto theft. I think that's interesting.

I have noticed that most Jewish players do command a small premium (like Barney Pelty), but I think it's because there is a niche collectors market for just Jewish players. I do the rookie card thing. You may collect only cardinals players. Some just collect Negro League players. Many collect only jewish player cards. To each his own.

[Leon]

There are a lot of Jewish player collectors and many, many times the cards bring a premium because of that.

[oldjudge]

How could the cards of the chosen people not be worth more? Anything else would be mashugana.

[Aquarian Sports Cards]

Originally Posted by oldjudge

How could the cards of the chosen people not be worth more? Anything else would be mashugana.

actually you mean meshuga. meshuggeneh is a person who is meshuga.

[oldjudge]

mashugana. Noun. (plural mashuganas) nonsense, silliness, craziness, garbage (as in useless) (pejorative) A person who is nonsensical, sill

[glynparson]

There is frequently a premium on Jewish players due to increased demand. Like Leon stated there are several people who collect players with Jewish heritage there by increasing demand for their cards thus causing a premium.

[Aquarian Sports Cards]

Originally Posted by oldjudge

mashugana. Noun. (plural mashuganas) nonsense, silliness, craziness, garbage (as in useless) (pejorative) A person who is nonsensical, sill

you used it as an adjective, even your definition states it's a noun. meshuga is the adjective. let's take this over to the yiddish grammar thread

[Piratedogcardshows]

I can attest to there being a premium on Jewish players cards within the T210 set. The J. Erskine Mayer Series 7 that sold on eBay a few months ago is proof of that. Others such as Levy in Series 2 always brings a premium.

[Leon]

Originally Posted by Aquarian Sports Cards

you used it as an adjective, even your definition states it's a noun. meshuga is the adjective. let's take this over to the yiddish grammar thread

My dear grandparents (RIP) would be smiling. They spoke Yiddish when they got riled up and we never knew what they were saying....but if it was Yiddish it wasn't looking good.. for us.

[Exhibitman]

Not to pay more for a landsmann would be a shonda

[oldjudge]

Originally Posted by Exhibitman

Not to pay more for a landsmann would be a shonda

Oy, such a smart boy (if only he was a doctor).

[drcy]

Benny Kauff may have a bit of a premium because he was one of the best ever minor league players.

One might say Jewish players have a proverbial 'regional premium,' as certain players and teams have premiums in certain localities.

As a side note, I just found out that my friend's great uncle was the Jewish middleweight champion Al McKoy (Changed his last name from Alexander).

[Aquarian Sports Cards]

Originally Posted by drcy

Benny Kauff may have a bit of a premium because he was one of the best ever minor league players.

One might say Jewish players have a proverbial 'regional premium,' as certain players and teams have premiums in certain localities.

As a side note, I just found out that my friend's great uncle was the Jewish middleweight champion Al McKoy (Changed his last name from Alexander).

hmmm If you had said one of the best Federal league players I'd have to agree, but that was technically considered a Major League. His minor league stats were nothing overwhelming in about 1600 PA's.

[Topnotchsy]

Lots of Nachas reading this threads

[Billy5858]

So Pelty/Hindu impossible?

[clydepepper]

Wow! My edjumukashun continues! Thanks guys!

[Jewish-collector]

The funny thing is that Benny Kauff is NOT Jewish.

[IMAXMAX]

Oy Vey!

Originally Posted by Jewish-collector

The funny thing is that Benny Kauff is NOT Jewish.

[EYECOLLECTVINTAGE]

I agree that Jewish Players bring a premium.

My girlfriend is Jewish and her father collected and is so proud of these players. Even when we went to the Yankees Tiger game last year for old timers day, and Kinsler came up he goes..."he's part of the tribe". haha

[packs]

Jewish players bring in premiums without a doubt. People pay more money for Jimmie Reese Zeenuts than they should because he's Jewish. Even Hank Greenberg, hall of famer, gets Jewish tagged to his items because it's a major collecting focus for a lot of people.

[Exhibitman]

Originally Posted by drcy

Benny Kauff may have a bit of a premium because he was one of the best ever minor league players.

One might say Jewish players have a proverbial 'regional premium,' as certain players and teams have premiums in certain localities.

As a side note, I just found out that my friend's great uncle was the Jewish middleweight champion Al McKoy (Changed his last name from Alexander).

[Yoda]

Originally Posted by ullmandds

probably worth less to a palestinian!

Unless it is Yassar Arafat's rookie card.