Let me see your early career autographs!

[nicker10]

I recently got interested in collecting early career/rookie autographs of players. Just think its something different because even if a player is still alive and signing, those early versions of there signatures are at least a little more scarce. I have these three so far and would love to see what other people have.

[RelicSports]

I too love the rookie era/vintage playing days signatures. I have been weening down my personal collection, but attached are a few of my favorites (rookie Mays, rookie era Ted Williams, and a 1941 Ted Williams).

[JoeDfan]

My early Mick sig.

[thenavarro]

One of my early Mantles.

[Lordstan]

Originally Posted by nicker10

I recently got interested in collecting early career/rookie autographs of players. Just think its something different because even if a player is still alive and signing, those early versions of there signatures are at least a little more scarce. I have these three so far and would love to see what other people have.

Cool sigs. The show that Gwynn signed that cachet was run by my father and his partner. Tony told us it was his first show ever.

Here is the flyer, which was signed that day. I actually have a second copy of it as well.

[btcarfagno]

Willie Stargell during first two weeks in majors.

Tom C

[nicker10]

Originally Posted by Lordstan

Cool sigs. The show that Gwynn signed that cachet was run by my father and his partner. Tony told us it was his first show ever.

Here is the flyer, which was signed that day. I actually have a second copy of it as well.

That's really interesting. I was trying to find info on that show but had no luck. Thanks for sharing

[canjond]

Two for my favorite Mantles:

The first is an approximately 5*7 candid photo taken by a fan (and signed by Mickey) in 1951.

The second is a 1951 GPC. Great thing about it, the next afternoon, Mickey would go on to hit his first big league home run!

[bender07]

Originally Posted by canjond

Two for my favorite Mantles:

The first is a 1951 GPC. Great thing about it, the next afternoon, Mickey would go on to hit his first big league home run!

The second is an approximately 5*7 candid photo taken by a fan (and signed by Mickey) in 1951.

Incredible Jon. Wow!

[bender07]

Here's an early Jim Palmer which is for sale incidentally



Early Musial from '42



Early Doby from '47

[gnaz01]

One of my early Mick's

[Laxcat]

This has to be from '62 or '63. It has Ken Hubbs on the reverse. It was obtained at a Cubs/.45's game.

[itjclarke]

I posted this one a while back in another thread... a Mick sig my dad got in person in Enid, OK back in 1950 when Mickey's visiting Joplin Miners were in town. My dad was definitely tracking the local hero by that point and sought him out specifically.
Mantle ball.jpgMantle ball 4.jpg

Here's a few more that I wonder about---
A signed Gwynn rookie that's dated. It was an eBay pick up and I'm not sure it was signed that day? but thought it was cool regardless.
1983 Fleer Tony Gwynn signed.jpg

Also curious what folks/the experts here may think about the Snider, Aaron? Neither were sold as being early sigs, but they just looked older to me.
1949 Bowman Duke Snider signed.jpg1947-1966 Exhibits Hank Aaron signed.jpg

And finally this Williams and Koufax, though I realize it's possibly just the style pens that make me curious.
1939-1946 Salutation Exhibits Ted Williams signed.jpg1955 Topps Sandy Koufax signed.jpg

[daves_resale_shop]

Album page most likely signed during spring training 1938

[daves_resale_shop]

Album page cut circa 1939-40

[daves_resale_shop]

Circa 1940 burke

[daves_resale_shop]

Circa 1939 snapshot. Snapshot is dated by the original owner August 1, 1939. I think it was signed in either late 39 or early 40. One of my faves. Also used as An exemplar in the Psa autograph facts site....

[packs]

The pride of my collection: postcard marked June 19, 1908 sent by Walter Johnson to his friend Johnny in California. This was signed during his second major league season and between games against Cleveland and Detroit:



Rookie season signature of Roberto Clemente:

[kdixon]

Card Zach Wheat sent to his mother. Zach is on the right.

[smtjoy]

Cool stuff everyone. Early auto of my favorite-

1955 Spring Training Game Pirates vs Yankees.

[Runscott]

1948 Duke Snider
early 1950's Willie Mays
1940 Ted Williams
1973 Mike Schmidt

[Runscott]

Originally Posted by itjclarke

I posted this one a while back in another thread... a Mick sig my dad got in person in Enid, OK back in 1950 when Mickey's visiting Joplin Miners were in town. My dad was definitely tracking the local hero by that point and sought him out specifically.
Attachment 199166Attachment 199167

Also curious what folks/the experts here may think about the Snider, Aaron? Neither were sold as being early sigs, but they just looked older to me.
Attachment 199171Attachment 199172

Spectacular Mantle.

I'm no expert, but you can compare your Snider to my 1948 below.

[39special]

Originally Posted by Runscott

1948 Duke Snider
early 1950's Willie Mays
1940 Ted Williams
1973 Mike Schmidt

Love that Mays Scott! Is that Schmidt on a '73 Phillies ball?

[Runscott]

Originally Posted by 39special

Love that Mays Scott! Is that Schmidt on a '73 Phillies ball?

Steve, that ball has some '73 Phillies and some '72 Giants.

[39special]

Originally Posted by Runscott

Steve, that ball has some '73 Phillies and some '72 Giants.

Its a nice looking ball.The signatures look really bold!

[almostdone]

Originally Posted by Runscott

1948 Duke Snider
early 1950's Willie Mays
1940 Ted Williams
1973 Mike Schmidt

Scott,
Looks like I got the Reese from the same scrapbook as your Snider. Picked it up last year from Dave's resale shop. Put it in this display.
Drew

[itjclarke]

Originally Posted by Runscott

Spectacular Mantle.

I'm no expert, but you can compare your Snider to my 1948 below.

Thanks for the Snider comparison Scott, and nice sigs! To me, it looks like Snider's sig stayed pretty much the same throughout, to which I say "wow". Conversely, I'm amazed at how much my sig has evolved over the years, when looking at my safe deposit box sign in sheet. I have dozens and dozens of sigs over that have morphed (gotten sloppier and sloppier) over 7-8 years.

In looking at other rookie era Williams sigs, seems mine is prob not an older one.

[Scott Garner]

Here are the very early signatures of two players that I collect:

The 1st autograph was signed by HOF'er Nolan Ryan in 1967, the year before his rookie season in 1968 at age 20.

The 2nd autograph was signed by Johnny "Double No-Hit" Vander Meer in 1937, the year before his rookie season in 1938.

Finally, this is an extremely early autograph of Vandy in 1933 when he was in his very 1st professional season with the Dayton Ducks.

Enjoy!

[thenavarro]

Just picked up this early Joe Montana autograph. 1977 Notre Dame partial team sheet.

[Michael B]

Originally Posted by thenavarro

Just picked up this early Joe Montana autograph. 1977 Notre Dame partial team sheet.

This is the Notre Dame team that won the National Championship.
There are three other good NFL players on that sheet - Bob Golic, Ross Browner and Ken MacAfee. MacAfee and Browner are College Football HOFers. MacAfee went to Brockton High School in Mass. which was the rival of my school Waltham High. He was their best player. Our best player was Fred Smerlas, 14 year NFLer and two years ahead of me in school. Interestingly, MacAfee is an oral surgeon or orthodontist in Waltham.

[Mark70Z]

Fairly early Brooksie auto index card. I really like the red inked auto.

[almostdone]

Very nice Mark.
Drew

[Mark70Z]

Originally Posted by almostdone

Very nice Mark.
Drew

Thanks Drew!

Congrats again on completing the '54 Red Heart set; just awesome!

[Frozen in Time]

Originally Posted by itjclarke

I posted this one a while back in another thread... a Mick sig my dad got in person in Enid, OK back in 1950 when Mickey's visiting Joplin Miners were in town. My dad was definitely tracking the local hero by that point and sought him out specifically.
Attachment 199166Attachment 199167

Here's a few more that I wonder about---
A signed Gwynn rookie that's dated. It was an eBay pick up and I'm not sure it was signed that day? but thought it was cool regardless.
Attachment 199170

Also curious what folks/the experts here may think about the Snider, Aaron? Neither were sold as being early sigs, but they just looked older to me.
Attachment 199171Attachment 199172

And finally this Williams and Koufax, though I realize it's possibly just the style pens that make me curious.
Attachment 199173Attachment 199174

Super Mantle auto!! Note the Ruth-like, epsilon "E" in Mickey - a letter form that Mantle only used during 1950 with Joplin!!

Cheers,

Craig

[BrianinAZ]

Here is a Bruce Sutter signed in the spring of 1978.

[gnaz01]

Originally Posted by BrianinAZ

Here is a Bruce Sutter signed in the spring of 1978.

I went to high school with Bruce, VERY good guy!!!

[itjclarke]

Originally Posted by Frozen in Time

Super Mantle auto!! Note the Ruth-like, epsilon "E" in Mickey - a letter form that Mantle only used during 1950 with Joplin!!

Cheers,

Craig

Thanks for the input Craig, I'd always figured this one would be the same as his 1951/52 Yankee sigs. I'll have to look at it more closely compared to other early ones.

[meatloaf]

I have a few of these. Gold ink really pops on this early career auto. Too bad this minor league team no longer exists. Can't wait until Ken Griffey Jr makes it into the Hall.

[nicker10]

Just got this one in today

[Laxcat]

From the other Sigs in this "book" I believe his to be circa 1970.

[vintagehofrookies]

Jose Canseco- the Star is from 1986 and is unopened and the Madison Muskies was bought in a lot of about 15 other signed 1983 Muskies off ebay from a seller who was from Madison, WI. and said the cards were signed in the summer of 1983 for him
Barry Bonds- Bought off ebay from a seller from Pittsburgh who got the card signed at a Pittsburgh card show in 1987
Monte Irvin- Signed for a kid who was terminally sick in the early 50's and had total access to locker rooms (the boy died in either 53 or 54)
Frank Thomas- bought off ebay ($5) from seller who was from Birmingham and said he got the card signed at a Birmingham card show in summer of 1990
Al Kaline- Postmarked 1954
Tommy Lasorda- I have no clue if its close to his RC year or not but it looks old
Al Simmons- Dated 1928, so not his Rookie year but kinda early sig. regardless

[RelicSports]

I love that early Simmons exhibit/auto!

[mcgwirecom]

McGwire from 1984 I believe. 1985 at the latest.

[JMEnglish27]

Originally Posted by mcgwirecom

McGwire from 1984 I believe. 1985 at the latest.

That's AMAZING. Love it.

[niembre]

Early Bob Feller autograph on scorecard from a game he won on April 29, 1938

[Michael B]

Here are a few that are not baseball. They are all OlympianS who are known for the Olympics and other endeavors.

Bill Russell - One from October, 1956 signed in California on the way to the Olympics. One signed in Melbourne at the Olympics for the manager of the dining hall the U.S. team used. I just received a third one in the mail today from Australia that was signed during the Olympics.

Spencer Haywood - 1968 before the Olympics. He is being inducted into the Basketball Hall of Fame in September.

Jackie Fields - 1924 during the Olympics in Paris. He would become a world champion boxer as a welterweight.

Jesse Owens - 1934 at the AAU Championships in Milwaukee while still a student at Ohio State. You will see this one 'tombed' on ebay at a ridiculous price.

George Foreman - 1968 prior to the Olympics.

[Den*nis O*Brien]

Somewhat early for both players

[nicker10]

Heres an earlier career Tom Glavine



And an early Harmon Killebrew