Your "White Whale" .... and will you land it ??

[mybuddyinc]

"From beneath his slouched hat Ahab dropped a tear into the sea; nor did all the pacific contain such wealth as that one wee drop." – Herman Melville, Moby Dick


For the past 12+ years I have been working on a "mid-tier back" T206 set (Sov.350 - P42, plus 2 PBs ) ........ I sit at 519 .....


My "White Whale" --- Tolstoi Cross

It is a "cross to bare" as I don't see it happening ......


But, as they say --- "Hope Springs Eternal" .........

......... and yours ?????


Still, Fun, fun, Scott

[4815162342]

Tolstoi Cross


Holy smokes!

[ullmandds]

I currently have no white whale. It was the last t216 dots miller i needed for my run. I thought it could take a lifetime to find.

One day commercial fisherman mac wubben emailed me with my whale. Of course I had to reimburse him for operating costs!!!!

I'd surmise your whale is also other's whale!!!!

Any excuse to show dots!!!!

[calvindog]

Pete, which Miller card has that massive back damage? I want to find it and sell it to you for $2 million.

[brass_rat]

D303 Mothers' Bread Bressler and Lajoie

I think Bressler exists, but I'm not sure about Lajoie.

https://www.net54baseball.com/showthread.php?t=250083

[Seven]

If we're talking collecting in general, I don't believe I have one. The cards that I really want in my collection are ones all readily available if you have the financial means to acquire them, which I don't.


I suppose if I were really to choose something, a true white whale if you will it would be the Harrsion Studios Postcard of Josh Gibson. I doubt there even is another copy of this card in existence, and I'm pretty sure the only way I would ever own it would be if I suddenly inherited millions of dollars.

[pawpawdiv9]

my current white whale is the last card i need for my 1916-20 unc big heads set.
I missed on a poor version in Hakes a few yrs ago. But i need: PING BODIE

[z28jd]

My white whale is the 1887 Kalamazoo Pittsburgh team card, and I won't be getting it unless I decide to sell other cards to buy it. I have other cards on my wantlist that are actually in my price range, which I would get before the Kalamazoo card.

[tjisonline]

I like how you referred to it as “white whale” and not a grail.

I think many of us have white whales until they are “captured”. Then another one emerges. At least this has been the case w/ me & hobby friends. Strange though as with other hobbies, I obtained a “white whale” in each & was perfectly content every single time . Cards on the other hand…

For me , it’s the t206 Wagner. Zero chance of ever owning one.

[MuncieNolePAZ]

I have two main focuses. My WaJo back run and Pop Lloyd.

For WaJo it would be the T215 Pirate WaJo.
My Lloyd would be the 1910 Punch.

The odds of ever owning either are next to zero.

Thanks
Chad

[ullmandds]

Originally Posted by calvindog

Pete, which Miller card has that massive back damage? I want to find it and sell it to you for $2 million.

if you're referring to the blank back with writing...I'm not concerned. It's 1/2 and i own both. Arent u happy you robbed me on your red hindu chase black cap and herpo cobby...isn't that enuff?????

[ullmandds]

Originally Posted by brass_rat

D303 Mothers' Bread Bressler and Lajoie

I think Bressler exists, but I'm not sure about Lajoie.

https://www.net54baseball.com/showthread.php?t=250083

is that to complete the set???

[packs]

One day I’d like to finally land an E-90 Tris Speaker. It’s expensive but within reach if I find one I really like.

[mrreality68]

I hope all your white whales come true

I have had a white whale for the last 10 years or so

And may actually have a chance to get it (my luck having to sell some of my prized cards but it would be worth it)

And those who think they know me it is not the Felix Mendelssohn Joe Jackson on Goldin(although if I had the resources I would make a run for it)

My whale has to currently stay anonymous as I do not want anything or anyone to get in the way.

Hopefully by the September New Picks or October I will be able to share it


Stay tuned

Same Bat Time, Same Bat Channel

[calvindog]

Originally Posted by ullmandds

if you're referring to the blank back with writing...I'm not concerned. It's 1/2 and i own both. Arent u happy you robbed me on your red hindu chase black cap and herpo cobby...isn't that enuff?????

LOLOL I knew about the Chase, but the Herpo Cobb as well? Oh man!

[Rich Falvo]

Would love to get a T206 Lavender Cycle back to fill that hole, but they don't come up often. Really, any card I don't have for my Providence set yet is a white whale at this point.

[Lucas00]

'49 Schumacher Service Station Red Schoendienst. Released at a single gas station in Rural South Dakota, attached to packs of curtiss gum in 1949/1950. My hopes are not high at all.

[bleeckerstreetcards]

Originally Posted by Seven

If we're talking collecting in general, I don't believe I have one. The cards that I really want in my collection are ones all readily available if you have the financial means to acquire them, which I don't.


I suppose if I were really to choose something, a true white whale if you will it would be the Harrsion Studios Postcard of Josh Gibson. I doubt there even is another copy of this card in existence, and I'm pretty sure the only way I would ever own it would be if I suddenly inherited millions of dollars.

I share this white whale, Seven. But to add something new to the thread, this is up there as well... to pair with my signed 49 Bowman Paige.

[doug.goodman]

My White Whale is out there...

There are probably a few of them, and I know one did not sell when offered as Heritage lot #81887 in their May 21, 2021 auction. Maybe the consignor is reading this thread...

It's the 1915 Cardinals Team m113.


My smaller "off-white" whale would be the Virgil Trucks m114 with the NL Photo caption similar to the one below.

[bnorth]

Mine is more of a silly rare error card. I need the 1983 Topps Wrong Back with Wade Boggs on the front and Luis Aponte on the back. I have the one with Boggs on the back and Aponte on the front. Would love to get the pair together.

[CobbSpikedMe]

I collect Jersey City Skeeters cards. This is one of my White Whales. The 1915 T214 Victory Tobacco Hooks Wiltse Jersey City team card. I know Leon used to own it a long time ago, but he sold it when he sold his collection through his Heritage auction. I think the current owner is a board member, but I'm not sure who owns it now. I'll never be able to afford it if it becomes available again, but I keep up hope that someday it will reside in my Jersey City team collection.





.

[doug.goodman]

Originally Posted by bnorth

Mine is more of a silly rare error card. I need the 1983 Topps Wrong Back with Wade Boggs on the front and Luis Aponte on the back. I have the one with Boggs on the back and Aponte on the front. Would love to get the pair together.

All of our stuff is silly...

[bnorth]

Originally Posted by doug.goodman

All of our stuff is silly...

Yes but it is freakin cool.

[doug.goodman]

Originally Posted by bnorth

Yes but it is freakin cool.

Exactly!

[BioCRN]

1930 Baguer Chocolate "Joe McCarthy" in non-beater condition.

I'm not even talking mid-range or high-end, just not beat the hell up. Back stamp still intact without paper loss, front image not a mess, etc...

I've had a shot at a few from others and seen some raw on auctions/Ebay/etc over the years, but they've all been beaters.

They're not common, but they're not elusively mega-rare. I think I got a good chance at snagging this one day, but not in the past 10-ish years I've been looking one.

[Seiklis]

Same as ever, the final piece to the 1924 Diaz Cigarettes Cleveland Run, Guy Morton



I have basically 4 cards left I'd go all in on at the moment, and Guy tops that list

[calvindog]

I’d say mine is a Plows Candy Hal Chase. None have been graded and I’ve never seen one raw.

[Lucas00]

Originally Posted by calvindog

I’d say mine is a Plows Candy Hal Chase. None have been graded and I’ve never seen one raw.

I am jealous of white whales with images that exist 😆

[ValKehl]

As many of you are aware, I'm working on a master set of Sam Rice cards, and I'm quite far along. There are 2 Rice cards that I would trade my first born for if I could locate and acquire them - they are:
- 1922 Keating Candy. The pop reports show 1 exists, and it's autographed and in a PSA slab.
- 1922 Witmor Candy Type 2 (has the vertical back). The pop reports show 1 exists, and it resides in a PSA 1 slab.

[Exhibitman]

Landed mine a short while ago, so I am reassessing.

[LEHR]

My current white whale's....

Cardboard - I'd really like to add a sharp/clean Carl Horner cabinet. I've always admired them, but never pulled the trigger on one.

Memorabilia - I've always wanted to own a pre-1980 player or managers World Series ring. A Pirates ring would be a bonus. I will get one someday I'm sure but so far the stars haven't aligned.

[StraightRaceCards]

My current “white whales”

M116 Mathewson, Blue Background

Old Judge Pud Galvin

Was close to a large trade for a M116 Matty, but didn’t pull the trigger.

That’s what I love about the cards, the journey!

[deweyinthehall]

I don't really have any card related whales.

But I do have an ongoing 1978 project and I think I would consider images of Cito Gaston as a Pirate, Horacio Pina as Phillie and Steve Foucault as a Royal personal white whales.

[BillyCoxDodgers3B]

Originally Posted by Seven

If we're talking collecting in general, I don't believe I have one. The cards that I really want in my collection are ones all readily available if you have the financial means to acquire them, which I don't.


I suppose if I were really to choose something, a true white whale if you will it would be the Harrsion Studios Postcard of Josh Gibson. I doubt there even is another copy of this card in existence, and I'm pretty sure the only way I would ever own it would be if I suddenly inherited millions of dollars.

I never owned it, but at least I got to authenticate the autograph aspect of it (and the accompanying Jud Wilson, which I'd personally rather own over the Gibson due to his rarity making Gibson's autograph look "common"!).

[jlehma13]

Magie in beater condition.

[Seven]

Originally Posted by BillyCoxDodgers3B

I never owned it, but at least I got to authenticate the autograph aspect of it (and the accompanying Jud Wilson, which I'd personally rather own over the Gibson due to his rarity making Gibson's autograph look "common"!).

Would love to hear more about this Billy, the entire story of this set is pretty fascinating to me. There are practically zero playing days cards of some of the Negro League greats because of the time they came up. At least with guys like Charleston, there are some issues that people can pursue from his time in Cuba.

[Baseball Rarities]

Originally Posted by BillyCoxDodgers3B

I never owned it, but at least I got to authenticate the autograph aspect of it (and the accompanying Jud Wilson, which I'd personally rather own over the Gibson due to his rarity making Gibson's autograph look "common"!).

Stephen Greenes wrote a great article about this issue in issue #31 of Old Cardboard. Here is a link to some images.

https://www.oldcardboard.com/pc/harr...rrison-gal.asp

[BillyCoxDodgers3B]

Originally Posted by Seven

Would love to hear more about this Billy, the entire story of this set is pretty fascinating to me. There are practically zero playing days cards of some of the Negro League greats because of the time they came up. At least with guys like Charleston, there are some issues that people can pursue from his time in Cuba.

I only examined them for the sake of the autographs. That was nearly 20 years ago. How time flies. I just recall seeing the Gibson and Wilson. If there were others offered at the same time, they weren't likely signed, as they were not shown to us from my recollection. Unfortunately, that's all I can tell you, as I only deal in autographs. When you feel like you've seen it all, and items such as these show up, it breathes a bit of life into you, that's for sure. It was a pleasure to see them up close.

[sportscardpete]

Three whales for me would be a w600 Wagner, 1907 Seamless Ty Cobb, and a signed Wilt Chamberlain rookie. I think/hope I'll be able to knock off the first one at some point in time; the other two are going to need some luck.

[brianp-beme]

Originally Posted by packs

One day I’d like to finally land an E-90 Tris Speaker. It’s expensive but within reach if I find one I really like.

Quite a few years ago I was able to land an Off-White Whale when I picked up the below pictured E106 Tris Speaker, which has the same image as his E90-1. Probably the closest I will come to his E90-1 card.

Good luck Captain Ahab on landing your less Off-White Whale.

Brian

[judsonhamlin]

A couple of Mike Tiernan cards-
N173 and 1890 Old Judge

But #1 -
T206 Magie

[Bigdaddy]

I guess I'll always be chasing my white whale as I don't know what exists out in the wild. I am always searching for any photos, articles or other memorabilia of my grandfather, Hoyt "Speedy" or "Trooper" Webster, who was a boxer in the Army and fought professionally for a brief time after his discharge.

There is one photo of him that was found in his belongings after his death and another of him and other members of the 1930 Ft. Eustis Boxing team that I ran across on eBay. And a copy of a writeup and sketch of him in the 1930 Army Recruiting News.

The search continues.

[ClementeFanOh]

Always bittersweet to discuss, mine are:

1) a 68 Topps 3D Roberto Clemente and

2) a Cracker Jack Ed Cicotte

Trent King

[refz]

Not really a white whale in my eyes but I’d love to pick up a 51 bowman mantle, lower grade. Probably have to trade for it. I just never owned one.

Danny

[familytoad]

E210 York Caramel Waite Hoyt would be nice to find.

Maybe not a white whale, because if I do get it, some other card would immediately move to #1 most wanted.

I would like an Old Hoss Radbourne OJ card with clear image some day too.

[sbfinley]

Hage’s Dairy Tommy Bridges. I’ve never seen one in 20 years. I didn’t think it actually existed until a member provided me a scan of one about 5 years ago.

[kmac32]

T205 Kling Hindu card
T205 Pfiester Hindu card

[LEHR]

Originally Posted by familytoad

if I do get it, some other card would immediately move to #1 most wanted.

As a collector it never ends.

[joejo20]

Rose Company PC Lou Criger


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[bbnut]

I just picked up my white whale yesterday! A PSA 9 (OC) 1982 Granny Goose Signature series Rickey Henderson. Finding this in the bag of chips would win you a trip to the World Series! Supposedly only one available, but 14 graded by PSA (don't know about other companies), so I don't know what to make of that. I haven't seen one listed for sale anywhere in forever. So very happy even if there might have been something weird going on.

Sent from my SM-S911U using Tapatalk