One hell of a crossover

[zljones]

I finally sent my Addie to the SGC to have it crossed over. I did not do an official crossover, instead I cracked the PSA case open and sent the raw card to the SGC, it got a nice upgrade. Unfortunately I may have to sell this now.

Seems like T205 Addie Joss is becoming more common now, am I correct?

[sycks22]

Addie looks indifferent about the crossover

[HRBAKER]

Addie crossed over a long time ago.

[travrosty]

thats the problem with card grading. its so ridiculous that one day its a 1 , the next its a 2, or a 5? its so stupid all around to grade cards when we all have a pair of eyes.

[familytoad]

Well without holding the card in person, I would say the SGC card grade looks to be right. Nice card, although looking at my avatar may lead you to think bias on my part

I wouldn't proclaim the T205 Joss card to be more common. I think that just like any other valuable card, they appear in cycles, times when you can get good return for them.

I've beem spying around trying to find a good price on a SGC McIntyre, and looking through the last 3-400 listings, I see a half dozen Joss cards and only recall seeing one McIntyre (priced too high) That surely doesn't tell me that Joss is six times more available. it just indicates that selling a $900 card is more favorable than selling a $40 right now.

Folks here mention the cold temperature of certain sets, t205 mentioned frequently. That seems to be the case, but if you have Joss, Cobb, Johnson, Wilhelm in that set for sale, your cards are going to be pretty stable. Selling Beck, Austin, McIntyre, or Stanage could bring some low prices right now, so you may as well hold onto them...

[zljones]

Originally Posted by familytoad

Well without holding the card in person, I would say the SGC card grade looks to be right. Nice card, although looking at my avatar may lead you to think bias on my part

I wouldn't proclaim the T205 Joss card to be more common. I think that just like any other valuable card, they appear in cycles, times when you can get good return for them.

I've beem spying around trying to find a good price on a SGC McIntyre, and looking through the last 3-400 listings, I see a half dozen Joss cards and only recall seeing one McIntyre (priced too high) That surely doesn't tell me that Joss is six times more available. it just indicates that selling a $900 card is more favorable than selling a $40 right now.

Folks here mention the cold temperature of certain sets, t205 mentioned frequently. That seems to be the case, but if you have Joss, Cobb, Johnson, Wilhelm in that set for sale, your cards are going to be pretty stable. Selling Beck, Austin, McIntyre, or Stanage could bring some low prices right now, so you may as well hold onto them...

Thanks for that input on the Joss. I have been tearing my hair out trying to decide to either sell this Joss or my Willie Mays rookie card and Roberto Clemente Rookie card. I just got concerned because I used to see Addies pop up about every 90 days and now they seem to have been appearing more frequently and have been selling for less. I saw a graded good condition one sell on the bay for only 450 and it was about as nice as mine.

[Leon]

Originally Posted by travrosty

thats the problem with card grading. its so ridiculous that one day its a 1 , the next its a 2, or a 5? its so stupid all around to grade cards when we all have a pair of eyes.

Ignorance is bliss.

[Fred]

Zach,

The only plausible explanation for the PSA grade is that the original PSA grader wrote "2" "OC" on the flip and the person that handled it next misinterpreted his guide dog and mistyped "1" "MC" on the atual flip instead.... I hear that happens quite often at PSA...

[HRBAKER]

I think the issue that kept it from getting a higher grade @ PSA was the fact that there is no apparent paperloss.

[E93]

Is the back miscut/way off center?
JimB

[buymycards]

Fred, that was a good one.

[novakjr]

Why have a MC on a 1? By registry standards, that card would've been the equivalent of a NEGATIVE 1. Something doesn't quite make sense about that..

[zljones]

Originally Posted by E93

Is the back miscut/way off center?
JimB

O yea, it quite a bit off.

[DerekD]

Originally Posted by novakjr

Why have a MC on a 1? By registry standards, that card would've been the equivalent of a NEGATIVE 1. Something doesn't quite make sense about that..

It still would count as a 1 on the registry.

9Q = -2
8Q = -2
7Q = -2
6Q = -2
5Q = -2
4Q = -2
3Q = -1
2Q = -1
1Q & 1.5Q = no deduction

[novakjr]

Originally Posted by DerekD

It still would count as a 1 on the registry.

9Q = -2
8Q = -2
7Q = -2
6Q = -2
5Q = -2
4Q = -2
3Q = -1
2Q = -1
1Q & 1.5Q = no deduction

cool. I didn't know that they stopped deducting at some point... So according to that list, a 1.5Q counts higher than a 2Q!!!

[tbob]

Originally Posted by DerekD

It still would count as a 1 on the registry.

9Q = -2
8Q = -2
7Q = -2
6Q = -2
5Q = -2
4Q = -2
3Q = -1
2Q = -1
1Q & 1.5Q = no deduction

That's frigging goofy! A 1.5Q is higher on the registry than a 2Q and a card which is almost a 5 (excellent) and grades 4Q is the same as a card which is close to a 2Q but barely scrapes a 3Q???? Weird...

[zljones]

I have had to make the painful decision to sell this if anyone is interested here is the Ebay link. http://www.ebay.com/itm/290797546044...84.m1555.l2649

[michael3322]

I wrote about the silliness of it all a few months ago re: Dimitri Young's PSA collection...

http://www.net54baseball.com/showthr...ghlight=Dmitri