PSA vs. SGC for Chicle's

[jefferyepayne]

Hi all,

What is your opinion on what looks nicer for 1935 National Chicle football cards: PSA or SGC cases? I've got a bunch of each and am considering making them all look consistent.

thanks,

jeff

P.S. Looking for Stan Koska in this set

[Ease]

Imo, sgc slabs look better on everything, as far as resale, psa may be the way to go. Throw up a few scans if u can...

[jefferyepayne]

Sure, here are a couple.

Scan_Pic0001.jpgScan_Pic0003.jpg

How much of a difference in resale value do you typically see between a card contained within a PSA and SGC holder?

jeff

[smtjoy]

I think they look a lot better in SGC- Here is the pricing on the SGC 40 vs PSA 3 Nagurski-


Latest Auction Prices for: PSA 3 - Average Price: $3,585.37

10/9/11 eBay $3,585.37
11/14/10 eBay $4,350.00
2/7/10 eBay $3,800.00
2/5/08 eBay $3,000.00
2/5/07 eBay $2,462.50

Latest Auction Prices for: SGC 40 - Average Price: $4,058.44

11/25/10 eBay $4,058.44
3/27/10 eBay $3,900.00
1/10/10 eBay $3,671.97
10/18/09 eBay $3,550.00
6/27/07 eBay $2,500.00

[Ease]

The average of those five psa prices is: $3439.57
The average of those five sgc is: $3536.08

[MikeU]

Originally Posted by jefferyepayne

Hi all,

What is your opinion on what looks nicer for 1935 National Chicle football cards: PSA or SGC cases? I've got a bunch of each and am considering making them all look consistent.

thanks,

jeff

P.S. Looking for Stan Koska in this set

The most important question is what do you think looks best ignoring all else?