Name That Grade Game Is Over NO WINNER!!!

[lharri3600]

I'd like to start a new game on Net 54 called Name That Grade.
I'll post 5 graded cards and all you have to do is Name That Grade on ALL cards posted. After game ends, I'll post all full scans.
Game will run for one week. Winner will receive a $20.00 gift card form Applebees or Red Lobster, winners choice.
Here we go and good luck!

[Matt]

Psa 3
psa 2
psa 3 (mk)
psa 4 (oc)
psa 5 (oc)

[canjond]

psa 2
psa 1
psa 3 (mk)
psa 4 (oc)
psa 5 (oc)

[scmavl]

Marquard PSA 4
Bager(?) PSA 2
Lajoie PSA 3 (mk)
Bescher PSA 5 (oc)
Jinchman PSA 4 (mc)

[Frank A]

1. 3
2. 2
3. 2mk
4. 3mc
5. 4mc

[Ease]

Thanx Larry for the contest!
1. Psa 1.5
2. Psa 1
3. Psa 2mk
4. Psa 4mc
5. Psa 4mc

[ChiefBenderForever]

4
3
3
5
5


8675309

[ullmandds]

Thanks LArry...

psa 2
psa3
psa3 mk
psa4 oc
psa3 oc

But knowing psa they're probably all higher!!!!

[dstraate]

3
2
A
4oc
3oc

[nebboy]

Marquard (Hands at Thighs) - PSA 3
Baker (Follow Thru) - PSA 3
Lajoie (Portrait) - PSA 3 (mk)
Bescher (Portrait) - PSA 5 (oc)
Hinchman (Batting) - PSA 4 (oc)

[t206hound]

Marquard - 2.5
Baker - 1.5
Lajoie - 4.0MK
Bescher - 5.0 (no qualifier)
Hinchman - 5.0MC

[3-2-count]

Hi Larry. I'll take a shot......

1.5
1.5
2mk
5mc
4mc

[teetwoohsix]

Cool idea Larry, thanks for the game !! For the record, my answers would be completely different if these were graded by SGC. Here goes.........

Marquard-5 EX

Baker- 4 V/G-EX

Lajoie- 4 V/G-EX (mk)

Bescher-5 EX

Hinchman-5 EX

[sportscardpete]

1. 2
2. 2
3. 3 MK
4. 5
5. 5 mc

[milkit1]

Marquard -2
Baker - 1
lajoie -3mk
Beached - authentic
Hinchman- 4oc

[milkit1]

Good game by the way!

[alanu]

Marquard - 2.5
Baker - 2
Lajoie - 2 (MK)
Bescher - 6 (OC)
Hinchman - 4 (MC)

[deadballera]

Marquard PSA 4.5
Baker PSA 3
Lajoie PSA 3 (mk)
Bescher PSA 4 (MC)
Jinchman PSA 5 (mc)


thanks

Todd

[novakjr]

2
2
3 mk
authentic (trimmed)
5 mc

Granted, these are all assuming that qualifiers were accepted.

If submitted with no qualifier stipulation.

2,2,1,authentic,1

[Jacklitsch]

Marquard is a 6
Baker is a 5
Lajoie is a 4(MK)
Bescher is an A
Hinchman is a 5(OC)

[CMIZ5290]

Marquard psa 4
baker psa 1
lajoie psa 4(mk)
hinchman psa 6(mc)
bescher psa 5(mc)

[tiger8mush]

(my guesses, without looking at what others said, so i'm probably way off haha)

2.5
3
3(mk)
7(oc)
6(mc)

Rob

[jcmtiger]

Psa 4
psa 2
psa 4 (mk)
psa 3 (oc)
psa 4 (oc

[Leon]

How much of a disparity in folks opinions can there be? The Marquard goes from a 1.5 to a 6. LOL

[glchen]

Psa3
psa1.5
psa3mk
psa4mc
psa4mc

[GasHouseGang]

Marquard (Hands at Thighs) - Beautiful front, paper loss on back PSA 2
Baker (Follow Thru) - PSA 1.5
Lajoie (Portrait) - PSA 3 MK
Bescher (Portrait) - PSA 4 OC
Hinchman (Batting) - PSA 5 MC

[Matt]

Originally Posted by Leon

How much of a disparity in folks opinions can there be? The Marquard goes from a 1.5 to a 6. LOL

I think the rub is between what it should be graded given the PL and the possibility that PSA missed the PL altogether. Given the nature of the 'game', the actual grades given are probably going to be off from what they should have been.

[Tsaiko]

Marquard 2
Baker 3
Lajoie 2
Bescher 3
Hinchman 4

[Matthew H]

Marquard 4
Baker 2
Lajoie 4MK
Bescher 3MC
Hinchman 5MC

I don't think psa gives OC qualifiers to cards that grade under 5.

Thanks Larry!

[tbob]

I agree with the previous poster, these grades would be completely different if graded by SGC.

Marquard-3

Baker- 2

Lajoie- 2 (mk)

Bescher-AUTHENTIC (trimmed)

Hinchman-4 MC

[shaunsteig]

Marquard - 2.5
Baker - 2
Lajoie - 3 MK
Bescher - 5 MC
Hinchman - 4 MC
(bit harder on the last two without the back scans).

wondering if it'd be possible, at the end, to collate people's votes into a poll in order to see the distribution, and see if the mean agrees with the TPG.

Thanks for setting this up Larry!
--S

[npa589]

Rube Marquard: PSA 3
Baker: PSA 1.5
Nap Lajoie: PSA 2
Bescher: PSA 5
Hinchman: PSA 6 (MC)

I'm new to this...so if I win - that's really sad! Ha!

Great idea, great game Larry!

[Jacklitsch]

Originally Posted by Leon

How much of a disparity in folks opinions can there be? The Marquard goes from a 1.5 to a 6. LOL

There is no doubt in my mind that PSA missed the paper loss on the Marquard.

[AndyG09]

Dang, Larry, using PSA makes this tough with their "throw a dart at a number" grading scale. I will give it a go. Thanks for the opportunity!

Marquard 5
Baker 3
Lajoie 2
Bescher 5
Hinchman 4

Best,

Andy

Originally Posted by Leon

How much of a disparity in folks opinions can there be? The Marquard goes from a 1.5 to a 6. LOL

We are talking about PSA here

Marquard PSA 2
Baker PSA 2
Lajoie PSA 3
Bescher PSA A
Jinchman PSA 5 MC

[Mikehealer]

Here goes Larry..

Marquard-5
Baker-4
Lajoie-4
Bescher-5
Hinchman-5 (looks like a Hindu back)

[Gradedcardman]

2.5
2
3 mk
4.5 oc
5 oc

[DJR]

.

[Browncow75]

Hey Larry, Thanks for the game!!
My guess:

1.5
1.5
2mk
4mc
3mc

[Peter_Spaeth]

6
5
4
5
5

[chaddurbin]

Originally Posted by peter_spaeth

6
5
4
5
5

6.5
5.5
4.5
5.5
5.5

[E93]

2
1
3mk
5oc
5mc

[mark evans]

2

3

4 (MK)

Hinchman 5 (MC)

Bescher 5

Thanks for the game, Larry. Can already taste the shrimp.

Mark

[Harford20]

Marquard (Hands at Thighs) - PSA 1
Baker (Follow Thru) - PSA 1
Lajoie (Portrait) - PSA 2 (mk)
Bescher (Portrait) - PSA 4
Hinchman (Batting) - PSA 4 (mc)

[Bridwell]

Marquard (Hands at Thighs) - PSA 4
Baker (Follow Thru) - PSA 3
Lajoie (Portrait) - PSA 4 mk
Bescher (Portrait) - PSA 4
Hinchman (Batting) - PSA 5

[willworkforT206]

Challenging game since PSA's grading seems to be all over the place, but I'll give it a shot...

Marquard (Hands at Thighs) - PSA 2.5
Baker - PSA 1
Lajoie (Portrait) - Authentic
Bescher - PSA 5 (MC)
Hinchman - PSA 5

I'm pretty sure the Hinchman has a Hindu back and was graded without any qualifiers.

Steve

[ephus]

Marquard 2
Baker 3
Lajoie 3.5 MK
Bescher 5.5 OC
Hinchman 4 OC


Great Game!

[BearBailey]

1. 4
2. 3
3. 3mk
4. 6oc
5. 5oc

[Peter W Thomas]

2.5
2.0
2.0 mk
5 oc
3 oc