Buy or Trade for 41 Goudey Coffman / Warstler

[Archive]

Posted By: Jeff Schwarz

To piggy back on a recent post, I need just the Coffman and Warstler to finish the 41 Goudey set. As long as it has not been run over by a bus, I will pay $100 for the Coffman and $200 for the Warstler. Also have many pre-war cards to trade as well as 41 Goudeys of Heffner, Kramer, Case, Wyatt, Wright, and Todd. Thanks. Please end my search!

[Archive]

Posted By: John Harrell

I feel your pain. I've been trying to put this set to bed for 2 years. Finally found a Coffman last year but still need the Crouch. I think Crouch and Coffman are both SP's from this set.

John

[Archive]

Posted By: Jeff Schwarz

According to the Standard Catalog, neither the Crouch or the Coffman is a short print, although the Warstler is. Does anyone have any info on these gorgeous pieces of cardboard? Finishing this set was a 2008 goal and I will be happy to trade or pay generously for these two cards. Thanks.

[Archive]

Posted By: John Harrell

Jeff,

I'm simply basing my opinion on what I've seen. I see lots of Sullivans, Fletchers, and other listed SPs compared to Coffmans and Crouch's. From my perspective, they are much harder finds than most of the listed SPs.

John

[Archive]

Posted By: Brian

I've been working on a 1941 Goudey Master set for about 4 years now. I'm down to the last 7. I agree that the Coffman and Crouch cards are much more difficult than the other non-SP cards. If you're looking to wrap up these sets, confirm what you are looking for and I'll take a look in my stock. I've got about 300 of these cards ranging from PSA 8 to total crap. I am very interested to know what you have available. and if you have any of the card/color combinations that I am still searching for. My master set can be found on the 1941 Goudey Master set page of the PSA registry.

[Archive]

Posted By: Jeff Schwarz

Hi. Thanks for responding. Hopefully, we can help each other out. I have a red Todd, blue Heffner, red Kramer, blue Case, yellow Case, red Wright, red Wyatt, and a red Heffner. Any luck? Most of mine are far from mint (unfortunately) and would take virtually any condition for the Warstler and Coffman. Email me if you want to take this off the board. Thanks.



edited to add that if you have a Coffman and/or Warstler available, I would also gladly trade a better condition card of mine for a lesser one of yours so you could upgrade your master set.

Edited to add that I have a red Ambler in my collection and would trade you that one to help you.

[Archive]

Posted By: Brian

I just went through and did an inventory of my 41 Goudey's to make sure I had accurate counts. I do have an extra Coffman (in green) in about G/VG but I don't have it in hand yet. I should have it next week.

I've got all the cards you list (including a Ambler in Red in PSA 6 coming back from PSA right now).

I'm sure we can work something out though. I'm always looking for any of the 5SP's, Crouch, Tobin and Coffman cards so I can complete my master set or finish up an extra set. If you have an upgrade for me I'd be very interested to consider that as well.

As a side project I'm looking to get scans of miscut cards, the worse the miscut the better.

[Archive]

Posted By: Jeff Schwarz

Brian, Thanks, that's great. We will try and get you that upgrade as well. I am running a basketball tourney all weekend but will get you some scans no later than Monday.