1935 Goudey master set question

[jason.1969]

Am seeing discrepancies across different sources as to which "Picture 1" puzzle back goes with the following three cards.

• Terry-Schumacher-Mancuso-Jackson
• West-Melillo-Blaeholder-Coffman
• Wilson-Allen-Jonnard-Brickell

To clarify, all have variations with a Picture 1 (Tigers Team Photo) back. The question is whether for example the Terry card is 1J vs 1K.

If you have any of these three cards with Picture 1 back I would love to know which part (letter) of the picture it is.

[jayshum]

Here's what I have:

Terry-Schumacher-Mancuso-Jackson - 1K
West-Melillo-Blaeholder-Coffman - 1F
Wilson-Allen-Jonnard-Brickell - 1E

I can post some pictures if you want to see them.

[jason.1969]

Originally Posted by jayshum

Here's what I have:

Terry-Schumacher-Mancuso-Jackson - 1J
West-Melillo-Blaeholder-Coffman - 1F
Wilson-Allen-Jonnard-Brickell - 1E

I can post some pictures if you want to see them.

Thanks so much. If you're willing to post a pic of the Terry back, I'd love it.

[LuckyLarry]

[jason.1969]

Originally Posted by LuckyLarry

This chart is part of what I’m trying to reconcile. Note that it shows Terry as 1K but the card itself (post above) is 1J. Am wondering if the text on the card is a typo and that the true puzzle position is K or if various articles simply provide the wrong info on the card.

[LuckyLarry]

Jason: I’ll check my cards when I return home on Tuesday.
Larry

[jayshum]

Originally Posted by jason.1969

This chart is part of what I’m trying to reconcile. Note that it shows Terry as 1K but the card itself (post above) is 1J. Am wondering if the text on the card is a typo and that the true puzzle position is K or if various articles simply provide the wrong info on the card.

Sorry, my bad with a typo on my original post. The Terry card is 1K. Ruth is on the 1J. I corrected my original post.

The chart that Larry posted is what I used when I was putting together my 1935 Goudey master set, and it is correct for all of the cards.

[jason.1969]

Originally Posted by jayshum

Sorry, my bad with a typo on my original post. The Terry card is 1K. Ruth is on the 1J. I corrected my original post.

The chart that Larry posted is what I used when I was putting together my 1935 Goudey master set, and it is correct for all of the cards.

Ah, that explains it! Thanks to you and Larry both for the assistance.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk