Carl Hubbell PSA basic ser

[mq711]

Checked the PSA Registry to ascertain which cards are included in a Carl Hubbell basic set and was shocked to learn that none existed. On that note, I plan on starting one and would appreciate input on which cards should be included. I’ve included a list of “potential” cards; all thoughts are appropriate before I contact PSA.

1933 Goudey #230 or 234 (similar to what is on Mel Ott’s set)
1933 Goudey Sport Kings #42
1934 Goudey #12
1934 Batter-up #5
1935 Diamond Stars #39
1939 Play Ball #53
1940 Play Ball #87
1941 Goudey #20
1941 Play Ball #6

[Phil68]

Would a '36 Goudey Wide Pen be considered basic?

[Phil68]

Originally Posted by mq711

Checked the PSA Registry to ascertain which cards are included in a Carl Hubbell basic set and was shocked to learn that none existed. On that note, I plan on starting one and would appreciate input on which cards should be included. I’ve included a list of “potential” cards; all thoughts are appropriate before I contact PSA.

1933 Goudey #230 or 234 (similar to what is on Mel Ott’s set)
1933 Goudey Sport Kings #42
1934 Goudey #12
1934 Batter-up #5
1935 Diamond Stars #39
1939 Play Ball #53
1940 Play Ball #87
1941 Goudey #20
1941 Play Ball #6

I'm not a player-set builder, so I'm not sure if those sets generally only pertain to playing days?
The '43 Hubbell is pretty cool (R302). Not too easy to find. Obviously, the fleer stuff from 60-61 and I believe he was in that AWFUL sport thrills set from the late 40's?

[swarmee]

Basic and Master sets are from playing days only. Super sets can include cards from all years.
You're missing 1941 Double Play and maybe the 1943 MP&Co strip card. I would say that the Wide Pen would not be in a basic set since it's a premium, right?