Lou Gehrig & Babe Ruth opinions

[Augy44]

I'm sorry I just cannot get a larger scan of this signed album page. It is circa 1934 with Ruth, Gehrig, Rolfe and a couple others. What do you guys think of the signatures?

[Augy44]

Was able to get a better scan...Please provide any opinions you guys may have on the Gehrig and/or Ruth. I think they are legit, but just look a little different than what I am used to seeing. Thanks!

[Westsiders]

I don't like either one...but you may want to wait for some of the big boys to jump in.

[Duluth Eskimo]

I don't like the Gehrig or Ruth. I also don't like the Red Rolfe. The others I don't have an opinion.

[sycks22]

Don't like either. Gehrig was very loosely signed and all of his signatures I've seen are very clean and direct. Best of luck.

[GrayGhost]

I don't like Lou or Babe either. Red maybe, but not quite looking right to me.

[GoldenAge50s]

Looks like the Ruth was entered into that open space later on--doesn't fit the flow of the page, nor does the Gehrig.

[Scott Garner]

Originally Posted by GoldenAge50s

Looks like the Ruth was entered into that open space later on--doesn't fit the flow of the page, nor does the Gehrig.

That's exactly what I was thinking Fred!
Also note that the "Babe Ruth" appears to be signed over the sigs directly above and below it.

[bender07]

Originally Posted by GoldenAge50s

Looks like the Ruth was entered into that open space later on--doesn't fit the flow of the page, nor does the Gehrig.

I'm not a Ruth or Gehrig expert, but you're right, they look forced on to the page.

[Augy44]

Thanks for all the feedback guys, very helpful!