Your opinions Please. Beatles

[jeffects]

Hi Everyone. I hope this works, I've never posted photo's before. I realize this is primarily for sports but I know a lot of you are knowledgeable in other areas as well. Can you please give me your opinions on these three Beatles autographs. They were supposedly signed around the same time. I will provide more information on their origins if anyone's interested. Thanks in advance for any help.

Jeff

[barrysloate]

They don't look good to me.

Just wanted to add that unless their signatures varied greatly, they do not match others I have seen.

[jeffects]

That's what intrigued me also. They are vastly different. I certainly don't believe that any two of the three are legit and I've been looking at Beatles signatures for years. Thanks for taking the time to respond.

[David Atkatz]

Their signatures did vary greatly in time.
The "multicolor" set is definitely good. I feel pretty strongly positive towards the third set.
I don't think the first set is genuine.

[barrysloate]

David- on the multicolor group the John Lennon looks strange, and the "G" of George looks different than on other signatures I've seen. The Ringo looks fine and the Paul looks okay too.

[David Atkatz]

Originally Posted by barrysloate

David- on the multicolor group the John Lennon looks strange, and the "G" of George looks different than on other signatures I've seen. The Ringo looks fine and the Paul looks okay too.

It's an early set, Barry. Those are the "first style" Lennon and Harrison signatures. Nothing at all wrong with them.

Take a look at Frank Caiazzo's website:

http://www.beatlesautographs.com/

There's a set offered that was signed in January 1963. Compare it with this one.

[barrysloate]

Thanks David, I'll check it out.

[barrysloate]

I can see the signatures changed quite a bit over time...Caiazzo has some beautiful items. Never saw those four photos of the Beatles signing for their fans.