Babe Ruth cut signature, need your opinion?

[kenjrrice]

So here is my question. I have a Ruth cut signature, 1 inch by 3 inches. I have 2 options with this

1) Place on an 3x5 index card

2) Place at the bottom of an Artvue Hall of Fame plaque of the Babe

Which do you guys think would be more appealing to a buyer? To have a cut on an index card or on a sepia HOF plaque of the Babe?

Thanks for your help everyone!

[Vintagedegu]

-

[perezfan]

Same opinion... as a buyer, I would much rather just bid on the cut itself. Attaching it to an index card or HOF Plaque would steer me away from bidding on it. I think these things should be left in their purest form.

If you must do one or the other however, I agree with CS Bolay that an Index Card is preferable to a Plaque. I like to mat them beneath a photo, but that's just my 2 cents...

[RichardSimon]

Leave it alone!

[kenjrrice]

Thanks guys! Question for you though - would you sell it as is, or get it slabbed by PSA or BVG/JSA? Has a full JSA cert already.

Do you prefer the cut by itself or slabbed?

Again, the help is much appreciated!