Not a 19th century ticket, but 115 years old
Looks to be this game played at Bennett Park:
https://www.baseball-reference.com/b...90607310.shtml
What is crazy is none of the A's HoF players from that year played (Chief Bender, Eddie Collins (who would debut later that year), Eddie Plank, Rube Waddell ), nor did second year Detroit player Ty Cobb (who according to the Aug 11, 1906 Sporting Life was out on leave due to illness and an operation at a local hosptal).
Only HoF player to play in the game was Sam Crawford who went 0 for 4, but had a RBI