I'd done both- shot them with a 39 megapixel back and lit with studio strobes, and scanned with a canon scanner.
In the end, with equal tweeking in photoshop, it's a tossup. But it's a whole lot easier with the scanner, and if you don't have the proper lighting at your disposal, it's definitely better with the scanner.
If you're getting weird highlights from the scanner turn the slab a different direction and try it again- that often helps.
|