As they are wildly different era's and its the bat that really matters for these two, here's the OPS+ count:
Seasons 170 or over OPS+: Belle 3 (1 was 194, only season over 179 for either), Snider 1.
Seasons 160 or over OPS+: Snider 3, Belle 3
Seasons 150 or over OPS+ Snider 4, Belle 4
Seasons 140 or over OPS+: Snider 7, Belle 6
Seasons 130 or over OPS+ Snider 11, Belle 7
Seasons 120 or over OPS+ Snider 13, Belle 8
Seasons 110 or over OPS+: Snider 15, Belle 9
Seasons 100 or over OPS: Snider 15, Belle 10
Seasons below 100 OPS+ (all partial): Belle 2, Snider 3
I don’t see in the dataset a case that Snider’s productive career was anywhere near Belle’s in length.
Belle’s absolute peak is perhaps a little better than Sniders, which is entirely independent of career length. He has the best single season, but after that it’s a draw until Snider’s longevity has him winning the bottom half by ~50% margins.
They do not seem to be similar type careers.
|