Most likely year is 1890 as that was the only year that Cleveland and Buffalo were together in a League (the Players League), often times while on the road a team would sit for portraits in a different city thus the Cleveland player on a Buffalo mount. I don't immediately recognize the player so he is probably one of the lesser known guys on that team such as McGill, Stynes, Budd, etc.
I don't have the time right now to do too much searching but that should be a good start.
|