[Archive]

Posted By: Richard Masson

Eye appeal definitely does not factor into the grading of diamonds and pearls. There is an objective measurement of clarity and brilliance which can be measured.

Topps cards in holders may be commoditized by grade.
Old Judges, because picture clarity matters, simply cannot.

What about a caramel card graded 1 or 2 because of small insignificant paper loss on the back, otherwise Ex, versus a creased, dirty and worn card of the same grade. Which would you rather have? Which will consistently trade for a higher price? You can't take judgement out of the equation.
And the less subjective judgement in the hands of the grader, the better.