Quote:
Originally Posted by Peter_Spaeth
Ah. Well if that's what the OP meant, I might rank Seaver even higher than you do.
|
I think Maddux, Randy and Seaver are all very, very similar in overall value. Pedro has the best peak of them all, but too short a career to best them. I think it’s clearly Clemens at the top if we don’t punish for steroids. I think it’s hard to put anyone over him in the post-war period entirely. His career is ridiculous, dominating from age 23 through age 43.