Posted By:
Misunderestimated (Brian H.)I think Groups 2 and 3 will likely yield some HOFers.
Group 1 I'm not so sure about. The current HOFers who are a very large part of Group 1 seem very reluctant to elect anyone. While I think the pressure on them will increase with the parred down "top 10" candidates it still may not get enough of these voters to agree that anyone deserves to join them. Alot of these guys seem to want to avoid watering down the Hall even if it means keeping out deserving players who are good enough but not really off-the-chart great.
I think we are due for at least one or two more Umps (not sure who, but likely Umps from the later half of the 20th century)
Marvin Miller seems like a clear inductee too. I guess a committee that was promanagament and hated free agency might see him as the devil incarnate and refuse him admission. This would be a real shame because he's an very old man who much deserves induction in his lifetime.
I have a bunch of pre-WWII players I would love to see in the HOF but I have no reason to believe any one of them has any special support... except maybe Dummy Hoy who really doesn't measure up as player but would make a good story for the Hall. There will likely be some pressure to put in Shoeless Joe too -- his "lifetime ban" should have expired since his death but I doubt the Hall with let that happen... especially while Pete Rose is being held in abeyance.
The top managers not in the HOF are probably LaRussa, Cox and Torre who are not yet eligible (unless that got changed). Dick Williams is the best eligible and I think he's come close. He compares favorably with LaSorda but is hardly loved like Tommy was and is. (he's post-baseball record does him no favors either)
I think there are some Negro League (or pre-Negro League Blacks) who ought to be in (and at least one that should not have gotten in last year -- Effa Manley). I would not expect to see any more added for quite some time since the mass-induction.
Perhaps someone will figure out a way to put Buck O'Neill in but really he belongs in the HOF for reasons other than his very good (but not great) play in the Negro Leagues. Along these lines I'd love to see some way of recognizing Bill James but I'm not sure how.