[Archive]

Posted By: Rhett Yeakley

Chris, I agree with much of your list, but have a hard time thinking Wagner is the second best player ever, unless you have Ruth & Cobb tied for first. Also, I find it puzzling that you would think Dizzy Dean is Overvalued yet you think Sandy Koufax is Undervalued, Really?
-Rhett

Edited to add: Greg, I like a lot of your choices too, especially Grove, he was incredible, also imagine if the Orioles hadn't held onto his contract for as long as they did.
Also, I agree wih Tinker & Evers being overrated BUT Chance was quite a bit better than those two and he would have made the Hall had he never played but just for his Managerial record. I guess I feel is is much more legit than his song counterparts.