Totally agree. I don’t actually know where that handwritten sheet came from. It accompanied the ball when I received it. My guess is the original owner wrote down these names after examining the ball and included it as reference for PSA. Then PSA probably quickly looked at the J.J. McGinnis in the list and passed over it as not important. It’s actually the most important name on the ball. So where would I go from here? If I resubmit, pay another $325 (for a multi-signed ball with McGinnity as primary subject), will PSA be likely to admit their mistake and issue an LOA…or more likely to dismiss it as an inauthentic autograph to cover their butts? If I resubmit, would I be better to include all this documentation or just start from scratch? I really don’t dabble in autographs so not familiar with how the game works. Looking for suggestions.
|