Posted By:
CatCards can be resubmitted to PSA to be reholdered and it is quite cheap to do so (new cert #?...I don't know, never done this). The question is: if one entity was reholdering a great number of cards wouldn't it raise a red flag to the grader? Certainly would seem to raise flags if the holders were pristine. Maybe Memory Lane was smart enough to put a big scratch in the holder before sending it back.
PSA Customer Service to Memory Lane: "It is our sincere belief that you should no longer store you holdered cards in the same safe as your raw diamonds...or at least put a small piece of bubble wrap between the two. It's just a suggestion."