[Archive]

Posted By: J Levine

Good to see some Phillies on the list (Allen, Buffington, Magee, Luz, Cy Williams, Ennis, McGraw, Bowa, Cravath, Simmons, Camilli, etc.)...

Personally, I would vote for very few of these guys.

My votes would go to the following:

Dom Dimaggio-- I know, the numbers thing but he was very good.
Gil Hodges- Way overdue.
Elston Howard- great team leader, great catcher, would have been a star on any other team.
Sherry Magee-- similar #'s to Ashburn and a great fielder too!
Thurman Munson-- would have been a HOFer had he not passed too soon.
Lefty O'Doul-- avg. was great.
Van Haltren-- good numbers, good player
Smokey Joe Wood-- same as above

Just my votes...a few others are very close on my list incl. Cravath, Cy Williams, and Trosky.

Who would you vote for?

Joshua