Posted By:
steve yawitzThe grade on that Holland is generous, but I don't think it's a complete affront to hobby sensibilities. At least not as bad as that Latham.
I know it's not a baseball card, but I just sold this one a couple of weeks ago. It was my most generously graded card (a PSA 7*) and I almost felt guilty listing it, though I was fairly honest in my description:
Still a nice card, but probably only worthy of a 5.5 or marginal 6.
*It had an 07XXXXXX cert number. I've never been into PSA numerology, but I remember hearing once that those certs came from on-site grading. I always suspected some surreptitious activity between the dealer who presumably submitted it and PSA.