I'm not good at this game but how about wrestler Frank Gotch? Both he and Wagner were 5' 11', and the eyebrows sure match, but I'll leave it to the experts.
Thanks for the game! Leon, I will pass on the T-shirt and take the $60 bucks.
Lovely Day...
gotch3.jpg
Gotch2.jpggotch4.jpggotch.jpggotch7.jpg
gotch6.jpg