There head is so far up there ass and have no business grading vintage. Look at this piece of crap '59 Mantle with worn corners and not great centering. They graded it an 8! This is not the only example, I have seen a lot of vintage graded cards and they are so over the map ie. usually overgraded. Make sure you hit the zoom function, 3/4 corners have serious wear. There is no excuse for this:
http://www.ebay.com/itm/1959-Topps-B...item4843665629