I see the "buy the label, not the item" mentality in cards and comics all the time. If it's slabbed grade X, that's what some people buy, even if the item presents poorly for the assigned grade.
That said, I don't know anyone who would knowingly buy a fake autograph and be happy with it just because the cert said it was okay.
I try to study and learn autographs to the best of my ability. However, in some cases, I like to have an informed second opinion. Ideally a reputable TPA would have the skills and knowledge to identify more deceptive forgeries that could fool even a relatively informed collector. Whether this is the reality or not is up for debate.
I have been really studying Mantle and learning from experienced collectors since I discovered I had some fakes. In a few short months my skills have grown quite a bit. I will state that I have seen plenty of TPA approved Mantles I would steer clear of. They **might** be okay, but they are not strong enough to erase all doubt. I guess I am saying that a TPA COA adds some value to me, but is not the ultimate deciding factor.
|