[mintacular]

Well, so let's say the Front and Back were miscut you could get the MC qualifier however if just the back is you also get dinged with the the m/c as well? How does that make sense? I think that is illogical. You could have a miscut front and back and get the qualifer and a dead centered front with miscut back yet the card would get the same grade?

Also, the Clemente centering does not meet the standards of a 6 but more importantly, why should the submitter be able to request a NQ? Why should the exact same Clemente be in a 6 or 8/9mc slab? What sense does that make and how is that consistent?

In short, while I can see that the Brooks back has miscut back, actually the larger issue is still relevant...