I think it's good to scrutinize the TPG's. No doubt they read this site.
I owned mostly BVG at one time. Many I'd crossed over to PSA received the same grade and one scored higher. I find them to be accurate -at least with all mine.
I'd have rec'd a 1 or 1.5 on that Murphy, accurately.
Things to consider; Beauty is subjective., It's just a hobby myth,
kind people DO exist., This grader's name could have been Murphy. Perhaps he had a blind-date that night and in a hurry to hit the lanes. Or Beckett doesn't provide random substance.
