Refund to retain a solid rep...........
If I were the seller of the card, and this situation happened to me, I would ultimately come to the conclusion that this situation could easily be taken care of by accepting the return and refunding the $$. Why?
Because I wouldn't want to leave a customer this dissatisfied- especially if he is willing to spend over 1k on a card. And I am not 100% certain the seller knew it was trimmed, or, meant to scam. I have bought v/g graded GAI cards that I've submitted to SGC and they either A) crossed to same grade or B) got a bump up- so I doubt SGC is just discriminating because of the slab it's in.
So I am in the middle on who is right or wrong, just have an opinion on how it should be handled from here.
Good luck on the outcome Todd- I hope it works out for you.
Sincerely, Clayton
|