Quote:
Originally Posted by vintagetoppsguy
I had this happen last night. There was a card with a BIN of $1250 with a BO option. VCP for the card in a PSA is $681 and SGC $688 (it was SGC graded). I offered $700 and received a counter offer for $1240 - $10 less than the BIN. Ridiculous douchebag!
|
Sounds similar to my experience. There was a card listed for $6500 (or best offer) and I offered $4500 which seemed like a perfectly reasonable price considering it was slightly nicer than a card in the same grade that had recently sold for $3850. My $4500 offer got rejected and I get a counter offer for $6400. Lowering the price 1.5% isn't much of a compromise.