[Brian Weisner]

Originally Posted by cfc1909

Correct me if I am wrong-SGC is willing to compensate you but they want a record of what you paid? So I believe they are stepping up to the plate.

Also if you truly believe this is a one of a kind, new factory cut brown Old Mill, I think you would not be selling but trying to get this added to the registry just like the Cycle Matty.
Instead it gets consigned to Goodwin where no one knows who the consignor is.

If SGC gives you any more than $100, they own the card as you were compensated.

If the card is truly brown, you don't need it labeled as so, didn't the Sid Smith bring brown money in a past Goodwin and was not labeled brown.

Once the card is under a loupe you can see it is brown-I think SGC has a loupe.

I am confused why it had to come to this, couldn't you have taken what SGC was offering and keep your card out of their holder as you know the card is brown. You can see this under a loupe?

I still don't understand why the card was never shown to any collectors. You both have been to my table at Philly with loads of wonderful cards and also to gatherings with collectors were everyone was showing unique & rare cards and talking brown Old Mill as a brown Reagan and a brown Revelle were present.

We all make mistakes, I think this can be labeled as a mistake and move on.

+1
Be well Brian