Barry, I think you may be right on Williamson. I was going off the top of my head, but I was thinking of the composite that makes up Anson in Uniform. The bottom line is, it is certainly not Anson. I think that the reason that some cards that have conflicting images and names end up the way they do is simply dollars. Is a card picturing Mighty Joe Young, but labeled Cy Young, worth more as a Cy or a Mighty Joe? Is the Yum Yum worth more as an Anson or a Williamson? This, however, does not make it right. Those of us working on the Old Judge listings have made sure that these rules are followed closely. It would be nice if other sets were similarily reviewed to make sure the listings are consistent. Or, will dollars get in the way?
|