Hi Mark! You have bought old board games and a baseball ABC book from me in the past. I have a June 28, 1896 Supplement to the Utica Journal that is a thin cardboard of about 5" x 9" that says Rules for Baseball Game and there are cardboard figures of baseball players. Reading it, there should be a spinner which is missing. I am not sure what this is.
Anyway, I have it for sale on ebay. On ebay I am
sfgiantsfan44
and my email is
alwysyakn@aol.com
Thanks, Andy Sandler